First Half MVPs - AL Central

Here’s our writers’ picks for the most valuable players in the American League Central.

Chicago White SoxPhilip Humber

Three different White Sox can claim the title of “First half MVP,” but Phil Humber takes the title narrowly over triple-crown threat Paul Konerko and uber-utility and web gem connoisseur Brent Lillibridge. Humber broke camp with the team only because Jake Peavy wasn’t fully healed from his July 2010 surgery to repair a detached lattisimus dorsi muscle under his right shoulder. Humber pitched so well in Peavy’s absence that manager Ozzie Guillen was unable to demote any of his starters once Peavy returned, opting for a six-man rotation. Humber is 8-4 with a 2.69 earned run average and went eight starts from May 6 to June 19 without losing (5-0). He has only been charged with four earned runs twice this year, yielding three earned or less in 15 of his 17 starts. He has been working deep into games and given the White Sox stability as they work out the kinks in other facets of the game *cough* Adam Dunn *cough*. Not only is Humber the White Sox’s first-half MVP, but he’s an All-Star and has risen to the level of staff ace. Eat it, Mets, Twins, Royals and A’s. Phil has come to fruition.

Travis MillerSouthside Showdown

Cleveland Indians Asdrubal Cabrera

This is a pretty easy one. Asdrubal Cabrera is far and away the Indians MVP. From the shortstop position he is on a .300-25-90 pace and has carried an offense that has struggled to hang runs on the scoreboard since April. Throw in his Gold Glove-caliber defense and this is a no-brainer. He is easily the most consistent player on this team and has kept them in the division race single-handedly. It’s a shame the people are robbing baseball fans by voting Jeter in at short for the AL instead of Asdrubal.

Mark BigelowDeep Left Field

Detroit Tigers Miguel Cabrera

There are legitimately four or five guys that I could make cases for as first-half MVP of the Tigers. Victor Martinez has stepped in and provided an excellent bat behind Miguel Cabrera, something the team lacked last season. Alex Avila has been the best offensive (and one of the best defensive) catcher in the American League, and Jhonny Peralta and Brennan Boesch have both easily surpassed expectations and have added considerable depth to the lineup. Even taking all of the above into account, the choice still has to be Cabrera.

A glance at Cabrera’s triple crown stats suggest he’s having a very good, but not outstanding, season. But when you also look at his secondary numbers you can see his true value. Cabrera in the top five in the league in batting average (6th), OBP (2nd), OPS (4th), Runs scored (5th), and walks (2nd). He’s also leading the league in intentional walks with 14. For the more saber-minded, he’s also third in the league in wOBA at .427, second in adjusted OPS+ at 187. No matter how you define an MVP player, Cabrera has been not only the Tigers best, but also their most irreplaceable.

John ParentMotor City Bengals

Kansas City Royals Billy Butler

For some reason a vocal group of Royals fans are writing Billy Butler off as nothing more than a glorified singles hitter with no position but they’re overlooking the best hitter on the Royals, and one of the best in the game, period.  No, he doesn’t hit for a lot of home run power, but he hits enough to produce, and his ever-increasing walk rate (it’s risen every year since he joined the big leagues) suggests a keen batting eye and patience.  Butler’s only 25 years old and is regularly among the league’s leaders in hits and doubles.  His combination of hitting ability, patience and durability make him the anchor of the Royals lineup (at least until Eric Hosmer gets in a groove).

Michael EngleKings of Kauffman

Minnesota TwinsMichael Cuddyer

The true MVP of the Twins is head trainer Rick McWane. If the Nobel Prize for Medicine is awarded based on quantity of patients treated, McWane is a shoo-in. Six players from the team’s Opening Day lineup have spent at least a month on the DL so far. And the bullpen and bench have been hit almost as hard. McWane is doing the work of five men this season.

For those traditionalists who insist that the Most Valuable Player has to be an actual player, I respectfully submit the name of Michael Cuddyer. Cuddyer’s numbers have not been incredible – .291/.360/.469 with 12 homers and 37 RBI through 79 games – but Cuddyer deserves the award for the simple fact that he’s been a solid presence in the lineup the whole season so far. On the 2011 Twins, that’s no small feat! In fact, for a good portion of the year, the Twins were putting out lineups every day where Cuddyer was the only player who wasn’t in the minors a year ago. He had a poor start, and for a while it seemed he couldn’t buy an RBI (though that was mostly the fault of the weak hitters in front of him), but he got hot in June, hitting .323 with a 1.004 OPS through June 29. Not coincidentally, June is when the Twins started to shake their early season struggles and play like a Major League team again.

Nate GilmorePuckett’s Pond

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for your Call to the Pen.

Tags: Asdrubal Cabrera Billy Butler Bradon Boesch Brent Lillibridge Chicago White Sox Cleveland Indians Detroit Tigers Jake Peavy Jhonny Peralta Kansas City Royals Michael Cuddyer Miguel Cabrera Minnesota Twins Paul Konerko Philip Humber

  • Pingback: A.L. Central First-Half MVPs « Southside Showdown | A Chicago White Sox Blog

  • Pingback: Baseball Blogs Weigh In: Uehara, Pagan, Red Sox | Forex News

  • Kevin Waisfeld

    Not to be rude, but I have no idea which ‘Vocal group of Royals Fans’ you’re talking about. Billy Butler has been one of the best double hitters in HISTORY through someones first few years of their career. This year, his power numbers are a little down but he’s still OPSing over 800. His OPS in June? 868.

    I have never heard anyone but you call him a “glorified singles hitter.” He’s been, without a doubt or argument, the best Royals hitter for about five years now. Really, ever since Mike Sweeney’s pummel. Then again, it’s not much when you talk about the Royals offense, especially over the last five years. However, I have no idea which “vocal” fans you’re talking about.

    If it’s the same ones who have been calling for Dayton Moore’s head since he was hired because Rany or Joe Posnaski didn’t like Scott Podsednick or Rick Ankiel, they don’t count, as besides what they read in a blog or too, they don’t much about the organization.

  • Kevin Waisfeld

    Also, a glorofied singles hitter would be Ichiro Suzuki, the best in history. There’s a reason why he’s put an OPS over 800 just once in the last six years (including 2011). Billy’s already on his way to three in a row, and he turned 25 a month ago.

  • Blaine Blontz


    I would agree with you about Butler being more than a glorified singles hitter and I think Michael Engle would as well as he chose Butler as the team’s first half MVP.

    Interesting stat on Ichiro, I didn’t realize that about his numbers. I’ve heard some say he could turn it on and put up decent home run numbers at the expense of his BA, but his OPS certainly doesn’t back up those statements.

    Thanks for the comments!

  • Kevin Waisfeld

    I would never doubt Ichiro’s potential to do anything (at least earlier in his career)

    There is no doubt that Billy’s power isn’t extraordinary yet. However, it’s also something that develops.

    Here’s a ceiling for Billy:
    Joey Votto at 24, 2008
    .297/.368/.874 OPS; 123 wRC+.; .373 wOBA; 24 HRs..BB% 10%, K% 19%

    Billy at 24, 2010
    .318/.388/.857; 130 wRC+; .372 wOBA; 15 HRs..BB% at 10%, K% at 13%
    Votto at 25, 2009
    .322/.414/.981; 155 wRC+; .418 wOBA; 25 HRs..BB% 13%, K% at 23%

    Billy at 25, 2011
    .291/.391/.809; 121 wRC+; .353 wOBA; 6 HRs..BB% at 14%, K% at 13%
    Votto at 26, 2010

    .324/.424/1.024..We all know how this ends up.

    Billy at 26? We’ll just have to hope for the same :)

    And finally, I’d just like to say, Alex Gordon has hands down been the best player on the Royals to date, this season. His WAR puts him as the #1 LFer in the AL, #2 in the MLB, and a top 5 OFer in the AL.

    He also leads the entire MLB, by a healthy amount, in outfield assists.
    (30% more than the guy in second. Who also happens to be a Royals corner outfielder), but that’s just a showcase statistic really.