Jun 26, 2014; San Deigo, CA, USA; San Diego Padres former pitcher Trevor Hoffman speaks during Tony Gwynn
Trevor Hoffman
Trevor Hoffman represents the only other candidate making his first appearance on the ballot who stands much of a chance of gaining election to the Hall of Fame, let alone with that coming this year. Hoffman’s care largely rests on how the BBWAA starts to consider relievers in the coming years, as historically the position hasn’t gained much traction (see: Lee Smith).
The closer position was revolutionized during the 1990s and 2000s and two players dominated the role. Not only are they the only two with more than 500 career saves but they are both over 600 (Hoffman has 601). Mariano Rivera’s turn will come up in a few years and his overall dominance during the regular and postseason (Yes, he got a boost there for being a part of many winning Yankees teams but he still produced in those opportunities every single time.) likely assures him of going in that first year.
Hoffman, a converted shortstop who found a home with the Padres after being traded twice in the minor leagues, will get his due in Cooperstown (as Smith will, eventually) but it may not be this first year.
Next: Can all five get in?