MLB Awards Watch: Top 5 AL Cy Young candidates thru April

1 of 6
Next

Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports

With month one of six in the books for Major League Baseball’s regular season, let’s have a look at who the front-runners are to follow up the Cleveland Indians unexpected 2014 Cy Young winner in the American League.

Corey Kluber came from relative anonymity to win over more voters of the BBWAA than Felix Hernandez could muster in 2015. For as strong and steady as King Felix was throughout all of 2014, it was Kluber’s second half that put him in a position to win pitching’s most coveted award. Kluber carried a 9-3 record with a 1.73 ERA, 11.0 K/9 and a 6.63 K:BB ratio after the Midsummer Classic for the Tribe.

In 2015, the conversation has shifted some. Kluber and the defense behind him are struggling. A few of names who will appear on this list would not have been in the conversation at this same time last season.

In the month of April from the 2014 season, 1,706 runs were scored by American League ball clubs. This year, with one full day of baseball left to be played in April, 1,510 runs have been scored. But last year, Opening Day was on March 30 — compared to April 6 this year — and the 15 AL clubs combined for 384 total games played in the month. That works out to an average of 4.44 runs scored per game last April.

In 2015 offensive output is on the rise. Through April 29, AL teams have played 316 total games. But the average runs scored per game has risen to 4.77. These five pitchers are doing their best to not let opposing hitters get the better of them.

Honorable mentions: OAK Scott Kazmir (2-0, 0.99, 30 K) and DET Alfredo Simon (4-0, 1.65, 15 K)

Next: Andrew Miller

5. Andrew Miller – 8/8 SVO, 0.00 ERA, 20 K

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

The tall, lean southpaw deserves legitimate consideration at this point. After the New York Yankees started the regular season with a rather hush situation in the bullpen concerning their closer, Andrew Miller is showing manager Joe Girardi and everyone else that a committee in the ninth inning simply is not necessary.

Many thought Dellin Betances would own the closing job after his outstanding breakout campaign in 2014. But Betances is back to doing what he did best as a setup man for David Robertson in 2014, which is setting up Miller for saves in 2015.

The Yankees are paying Miller upper-tier money for a reliever at $9 million per season, so it only makes sense to allow him the chance to dominate hitters in the ninth and groom the 27-year-old Betances some more with eighth inning duties.

Live Feed class=inline-text id=inline-text-5
3 worst trades in Miami Marlins history
3 worst trades in Miami Marlins history /

Marlin Maniac

  • Yankees' 2016 trade deadline sell-off wasn't actually a win for Brian Cashman Yanks Go Yard
  • Ranking every New York Yankees closer since Mariano Rivera Yanks Go Yard
  • Ranking Brian Cashman's worst pitching trades for Yankees Yanks Go Yard
  • The 3 best Cleveland Guardians trades of the last ten years Away Back Gone
  • Worst trade in Miami Marlins history Marlin Maniac
  • Not since 2003 when Eric Gagne took home the hardware has a relief pitcher won the award. In that season for Gagne, the Dodgers closer had as many saves (8) as Miller has now in the month of April, but did so in 13 appearances and 14.1 IP. Miller has only pitched 10 innings in April but all his other statistics look eerily similar to Gagne’s 2003 pace.

    The Dodgers’ closer also had yet to allow an earned run, had a K/9 of 15.1, a K:BB ratio of 8.00 and a WHIP of 0.63. Miller’s K/9 of 15.88, a K:BB ratio of 5.00 and a WHIP of 0.62 are all generally inline with Gagne’s. Perhaps where Miller separates himself from Gagne’s historic April of 2003 year is in the oppositions inability to hit him. Gagne had a BAA of .125 in April of 2003. Miller’s so far sits at .081.

    Of course, the likelihood of the BBWAA giving a relief pitcher a Cy Young has a lot to do with what starters have done that same year. When Gagne won, he did so quite easily over the player with the second most votes, Giants starter Jason Schmidt. Schmidt finished 2003 with a 17-5 record, a 2.34 ERA and 208 strikeouts. Those are by no means shabby numbers, but Miller has some stiffer competition early in 2015.

    Make no mistake though — Miller’s name is in the conversation for this award. He is arguably the Yankees’ best player, both hitters and pitchers included, in 2015. Right now, his WAR of 0.8 is bested by only left fielder Brett Gardner (0.9) on the Yankees’ roster. That’s saying something for having only logged 11.1 innings of work so far in the month.

    Next: Sonny Gray

    4. Sonny Gray – 5 GS, 3-0, 1.98 ERA, 25 K

    Bob Stanton-USA TODAY Sports

    The youngest player on this list, 25-year-old Sonny Gray was excellent in 2014 as a 24-year-old in the Oakland Athletics’ rotation.

    Gray was only drafted in 2011, albeit out of Vanderbilt University, but he is no aberration or one-season wonder. The scouting report has been out for some time on the youngster now and the competition still cannot find a successful approach to handling his stuff.

    Live Feed class=inline-text id=inline-text-4
    Rangers pitcher calls out Twins catcher for starting bench-clearing scuffle: ‘Idiot’
    Rangers pitcher calls out Twins catcher for starting bench-clearing scuffle: ‘Idiot’ /

    FanSided

  • St. Louis Cardinals Rumors: SP wish list addition, another brutal injury, top prospect call-up? FanSided
  • Watch: Twins-Rangers benches clear after Sonny Gray hits Mitch Garver (Video) Puckett's Pond
  • Shohei Ohtani's injury could have a direct impact on the Cardinals' free-agent plans Redbird Rants
  • Rangers vs. Twins prediction and odds for Friday, Aug. 25 (Sonny Gray is the truth) Puckett's Pond
  • 3 tiers of starting pitchers the St. Louis Cardinals can target this offseason Redbird Rants
  • Last year in an American League that featured outstandingly steady performances from the likes of Kluber, Hernandez and Masahiro Tanaka, Gray managed to twice win the AL Pitcher of the Month award. The first came in April and the second in July, proving to any doubters that his consistency and endurance were not to be trifled with in his sophomore season.

    This season, Gray’s hot start to the year is not far off from his 4-1 start with a 1.76 ERA a year ago. Gray has been an absolute workhorse in 2015 as well, coming in second in the AL for innings pitched with 36.1 through five starts. His 1.5 BB/9 manifests well above average command with his six total pitch offerings.

    Four of Gray’s five outings have been of the quality start variety. Only once has he failed to record seven innings of work in a game, which came April 17 against the Royals when he pushed through six innings of ball using 102 pitches.

    Next: Dallas Keuchel

    3. Dallas Keuchel – 5 GS, 3-0, 0.73 ERA, 22 K

    Jake Roth-USA TODAY Sports

    “Fear the Beard” might have been coined by Giants pitcher Brian Wilson in 2010 and he unquestionably started the rugged, swashbuckler looking trend in the game as well. However, in 2015, no one is making hitters fear the beard more than the Houston Astros southpaw Dallas Keuchel.

    The surprise Astros are 14-7 and in first place of the AL West. The Astros also eventually won the two games that Keuchel earned no-decisions in as well. The 27-year-old has been nearly flawless in his five starts, all of them quality ones. His fourth one included an extremely efficient 106 pitch shutout. He leads all AL starters in innings pitched, which is not all that shocking. Keuchel threw 200 IP in only 29 starts in 2014 and led the league with five complete games.

    Live Feed class=inline-text id=inline-text-4
    White Sox News: An old friend had a shockingly great start
    White Sox News: An old friend had a shockingly great start /

    Southside Showdown

  • Dallas Keuchel had an awesome quote after nearly throwing a perfect game for Twins Puckett's Pond
  • Pirates vs. Twins prediction and odds for Sunday, Aug. 20 (Back Twins' bats vs Bido) Puckett's Pond
  • Turns out Dallas Keuchel is joining the Twins after all; Joe Ryan placed on 15-day IL Puckett's Pond
  • 3 Braves waiver claims to make up for lackluster MLB trade deadline FanSided
  • This former Cy Young Award-winner could replace injured Reds starter Ben Lively Blog Red Machine
  • Opponents are not hitting the ball very well or hard off Keuchel so far in 2015, either. The BAA him this season is .130, the lowest in the AL. His ability to keep balls coming off of bats low to the ground helps his cause dramatically. Keuchel is yet to give up a home run and his BAbip (.165) against ranks second amongst all MLB pitchers with a minimum of 20 IP.

    While Keuchel and his beard’s league best ground ball percentage of 69.2 are doing wonders for his Cy Young contender status, his one shortcoming is that he does not strikeout a lot of batters. His K/9 of 5.35 in 2015 is down a touch from his career mark of 6.5. This can be overlooked by voters of the BBWAA if he stays on his current trajectory, however.

    According to baseball-reference.com, Keuchel’s 1.9 WAR before his fifth start was tops amongst all position players and pitchers across MLB. His ERA to open the month with at least four starts is the lowest in Astros franchise history for April, besting Roger Clemens‘ previous mark of 1.05 in 2005.

    Next: Felix Hernandez

    2. Felix Hernandez – 5 GS, 4-0, 1.82 ERA, 36 K

    Jennifer Buchanan-USA TODAY Sports

    King’s Court has been in full session at Safeco Field in 2015. Hernandez narrowly missed out on his second Cy Young in 2014, but so far this season, he does not have Kluber nipping at his heels again after the month of April.

    Yet to lose in 2015, King Felix is 3-0 at home and last impressed Seattle’s home crowd faithful with a 102 pitch shutout of the Minnesota Twins on April 24. Not even 30 years in age yet, Hernandez is approaching a number of impressive career milestones that should be conquered this season if his health stays intact.

    And there is no evidence to suggest the contrary, as the right-hander’s body seems custom built for his chosen profession. Hernandez in 2015 is aiming for his 10th consecutive season with over 190 IP.

    Live Feed class=inline-text id=inline-text-5
    After Honoring “The King,” Mariners Have Four More Games of Royals!
    After Honoring “The King,” Mariners Have Four More Games of Royals! /

    SoDo Mojo

  • King's Court in Session SoDo Mojo
  • Seattle radio host pressures Orioles All-Star to change nickname in awkward interview FanSided
  • The all-time single season performance Mariners rotation SoDo Mojo
  • Former Mariners All-Stars headline Futures Game coaching staff SoDo Mojo
  • When was the last perfect game and no-hitter in MLB? FanSided
  • By far the most well-known name on this list and as sure a Hall of Famer as there is active in the game today, Hernandez has it all. He strikes guys out at a high rate, he is consistent month-in-month-out and his plethora of plus pitches allows him to work deep into most ball games.

    Hernandez’s fifth and final start of April came against the Texas Rangers. He picked up his fourth victory, going 6.2 innings strong allowing five hits and two earned runs. He simultaneously passed Jamie Moyer for most innings pitched in Mariners franchise history.

    Hernandez cares deeply about his club and the city they represent, as the ace was almost apologetic to the fans when discussing his runner-up status last year to Kluber and felt like his 2014 performance was actually better than his 2010 one when he took home the hardware.

    With that added motivation behind him in 2015 and an offense now featuring a scary Nelson Cruz, it should equate to more run support and thus wins for Hernandez in 2015. Look for his name to be in this same conversation come September. The King’s track record speaks for itself.

    Next: Chris Archer

    1. Chris Archer – 5 GS, 3-2, 0.84 ERA, 37 K

    Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

    There’s a new ace in town, Alex Cobb. Tampa Bay Rays pitcher Chris Archer is off to an incredible start. The 26-year-old has a number of things going for him. He has a presence on the mound at 6-foot-3, power-pitching credentials with his strikeout totals and four very sustainable pitches, throwing only a slider and change-up as his off-speed offerings.

    Live Feed class=inline-text id=inline-text-3
    2023 Pittsburgh Pirates Trade Deadline Special | Who Will Remain a Bucco After MLB's Big Day?
    2023 Pittsburgh Pirates Trade Deadline Special | Who Will Remain a Bucco After MLB's Big Day? /

    Rum Bunter

  • The Blue Jays must sign a former division rival to a minor league deal for depth Jays Journal
  • Pittsburgh Pirates: Bob Nutting's Master Plan Starting to Pay Off Rum Bunter
  • Two free agent starting pitchers the Blue Jays could target as minor league depth Jays Journal
  • NY Mets: 1 trade, 1 signing, 1 prospect for Justin Verlander insurance FanSided
  • Rumors: Blue Jays could be targeting pair of veterans to round out pitching depth Jays Journal
  • Archer, despite also being right-handed, dominates left-handed hitters. In that regard, he a deviation from the norm. Lefties versus righties in 2014 hit .233 vs .259 against him. In 2015, Archer has limited right-handed hitters to a .147 BAA and .178 clip when facing lefties.

    Only Keuchel’s WHIP of 0.73 edges out Archer’s 0.74 for best in the AL by a starting pitcher. But Archer’s K/9 of 10.3 makes Keuchel’s mark of 5.35 look rather un-impressive at the same time.

    Archer is still relatively young and has not learned all the nuances of the game just yet, but the former sixth round draft pick is getting there.

    Playing for a team that defends well and plays in a home park that favors pitching over hitting, Archer has that advantage to counteract his relative inexperience. He also has the stuff to compete for a pitching Triple Crown, something he shares in common with Hernandez, but which Keuchel and Gray lack the makings of right now.

    Next: Time for management to scrap current BoSox rotation?

    Next