5. Don Newcombe – Brooklyn Dodgers/Cincinnati Reds/Cleveland Indians
Don Newcombe started his career with four All-Star selections in his first five years. In each of those four seasons, the right-hander posted an ERA of 3.70 or lower. He was a reliable pitcher and was relied on often while a member of the Brooklyn Dodgers.
Near the end of his career, however, his numbers declined and Newcombe was forced to bounce around from team to team.
His best year came in 1956 (ironically not resulting in an All-Star selection), where he won 27 games, posted a 3.06 ERA, and took home both the Cy Young and MVP award.
While Newcombe was great on the mound, he was great at the plate as well.
In 10 years, Newcombe hit .271 with 15 home runs and 108 RBI. He hit over .300 four separate times and finished with an OPS+ of 85.
Newcombe’s statistics began to decline near the end of the career, as his average during his last seasons dipped to .196 with no home runs.
His struggles on the mound led to his early retirement at age 34. However, in the 10 years he played, he was reliable on the mound and at the plate.
If there was a Silver Slugger award, there is no doubt he would have taken home a handful in the 1950s.
Next: Mike Hampton