The Philadelphia Phillies shocked the world with a six-year extension awarded to infielder Scott Kingery. Since he hasn’t even played a single game at the MLB level, the pressure is on him to perform immediately.
Put yourself in Scott Kingery’s cleats for a moment. The Philadelphia Phillies come to you with an amazing offer. You can sign a six-year deal with them, guaranteeing about $24 million. There are a few more years at the end of the agreement thereafter, adding even higher totals to your bank account. What do you do?
If you have common sense, you sign the deal. That’s because like Kingery, you haven’t had a single inning logged at the MLB level.
The Phillies doubled down on surprises Sunday. Not only would Kingery make the Opening Day roster. He also accepted the not-so-hypothetical deal outlined above.
For the second time in history, a player was signed to a multi-year contract without appearing in a game in the big leagues. The other, former Phillies farmhand Jon Singleton, agreed to a deal with the Houston Astros back in 2014. The plan became a massive bust for the Astros although their 2017 championship rings say otherwise.
Kingery has all of the makings of a future star. Even so, the Phillies have put him in a dangerous situation.
What could go wrong?
The stereotype about Philadelphia sports fans is one that concerns me. Though they’re not nearly as savage as the mainstream media makes them out to be, their passion can tear Kingery apart before he gets a chance to build his confidence.
More from Call to the Pen
- Philadelphia Phillies, ready for a stretch run, bomb St. Louis Cardinals
- Philadelphia Phillies: The 4 players on the franchise’s Mount Rushmore
- Boston Red Sox fans should be upset over Mookie Betts’ comment
- Analyzing the Boston Red Sox trade for Dave Henderson and Spike Owen
- 2023 MLB postseason likely to have a strange look without Yankees, Red Sox, Cardinals
Rewarding Kingery this early may help him buy the boat he has always wanted and assist the Phillies down the line when he deserves a lot more. In the present, it sets Kingery up to fail.
The good news is that the Phillies don’t even have an everyday job for Kingery. He’ll move between a variety of infield positions throughout the year, sharing time with teammates along the way. Kingery should see time at second base, third base, and even play some shortstop.
I also wouldn’t be surprised if Gabe Kapler tests him out in the outfield, as many teams plan to do with young future stars, making them versatile adds to their arsenal.
Phillies fans reward players who have paid their dues. No matter what argument you make, Kingery has yet to pay his.
Even if the fans behave kindly, Kingery has his own demons to conquer. He has a contract to live up to. His reputation is at stake far more now than if he was playing for the league minimum.
Next: Neshek and his “everyman” personality perfect for Philly
Still, I suppose this is better than holding him back in the minor leagues. All of the bad scenarios involving this extension are speculatory. For now, I’ll try to believe the Phillies gave him this deal because they knew it wouldn’t change a thing.