With a potential Phillies slugger on the horizon, fans and writers are in limbo regarding a last-minute signing for an RBI slot in the batting order, while general manager Matt Klentak is working within his financial framework to achieve that goal.
Subject to expectations:
While the Philadelphia Phillies faithful still remember the season-ending collapse, many have moved on. But others are reluctant to free themselves from the disappointment and bitterness of 2018’s August and September.
"IN OTHER WORDS: “New beginnings are often disguised as painful endings.” – Laozi"
For now, Klentak has added three new regulars to these lineup holes: J.T. Realmuto (2), Jean Segura (3) and Andrew McCutchen (5). Translation: The GM picked up baseball’s top catcher, a .300 hitter, and a productive bat to slot behind Rhys Hoskins. Yes, three of the first five hitters!
Will Klentak address the right-heavy lineup? Well, the exec currently has Odubel Herrera and Nick Williams, but he could be pursuing two free agents. He may ink left fielder Bryce Harper or third sacker Mike Moustakas, and either could hit between right-side bats.
By adding Harper, though, the Phils could possibly have Cesar Hernandez (1), Hoskins (2), Segura (3), Harper (4), Realmuto (5) and McCutchen (6). Yes, the need for a left-handed cleanup hitter is glaring. And the bottom two holes could have Herrera and Maikel Franco for deadly offensive length.
The RBI spots are another consideration: Analytically, the two and four slots have the most base runners. Currently, Realmuto will probably bat second with Hoskins likely hitting fourth. But if Klentak acquires Harper, he would handle the middle of the order, and Hoskins would slot second.
The Phils could have a fantasy league lineup or an American League everyday eight. Presently, Hoskins and Harper have 35-homer power, while Realmuto, Franco, McCutchen, and Herrera can launch 20 to 30 bombs. And even signing Harper for roughly $34-35 million per year is doable due to the team’s financial resources.
As for defense, management has shored up their backstop shortcomings and their corner outfield gloves. In fact, right fielder McCutchen is now their best outfield defender. Additionally, the red pinstripes have strengthened two up-the-middle positions.