Best offseason trade not made by Phillies GM
By Tal Venada
In November, 23 Phillies were available on the market including two named relievers, but general manager Matt Klentak now needs the better of those two setup men for the 2019 squad.
Unexpected developments:
Even though the Philadelphia Phillies faithful have long forgotten those autumn days due to free-agency distractions, that original strength is now weaker because of injuries and poor spring performances. Yes, early December’s excess has become March’s shortage.
"IN OTHER WORDS: “The minute one utters a certainty, the opposite comes to mind.” – May Sarton"
Out of the chute, Klentak was listening on most players but mentioning Pat Neshek and Tommy Hunter specifically. They represent commitments of $6.5 million and $9 million respectively. However, the red pinstripes had younger, inexpensive, successful options and wanted to move dollars and/or receive prospects.
On the other hand, the front office addressed the urgency for a late-inning fireman by signing David Robertson. And since they only needed one, why ink Craig Kimbrel when they already had three qualified relievers too many? Plug another hole, no?
This winter, the Phils learned proven setup men weren’t atop the wish list of many GMs. That stated, Neshek at $6.5 million probably didn’t draw reasonable offers, and he wasn’t alone in that unexpected situation. Apparently, many like-minded teams cut corners in their pens.
Many organizations opted for cheaper bullpen alternatives. Basically, they spent elsewhere despite having relief-corps shortcomings, or they elected for in-house candidates. But while some are at ownership’s limits financially, others have interest in bargains or injury replacements.
Besides Kimbrel, Ryan Madson is still available, but he like the top-tier closer is in a higher price range. Moreover, even though some national publications blame the hurlers for unrealistic expectations, clubs aren’t showing interest even in a $5 million reliever.
When camp opened, the Fightins had Seranthony Dominguez, Hector Neris, Robertson, Neshek, and Hunter for five bullpen seats. But they also had six moundsmen for their three remaining openings: Victor Arano, Adam Morgan, Edubray Ramos, Jose Alvarez, James Pazos, and Juan Nicasio.