MLB History: The 2000 RBI Club

Cap Anson

While Cap Anson had over 2000 RBI in his career, his inclusion on this list is still somewhat debated.

Anson’s first five seasons in the majors came in the National Association, the precursor to the National League. There were problems with that league however, as weaker teams would drop out in the middle of the season, and the NA was dominated by the Boston franchise. Yet, it was financially successful, proving that professional baseball could exist.

One of the biggest stars in the NA, Anson continued his dominance in the National League. He became the player/manager of the Cubs, or White Stockings as they were called then. Anson led the league in RBI eight times, and drove in 100 runs when he was 42 years old. Overall, in his 27 year career, he notched 2075 RBI, currently the fourth most in MLB history.

The biggest problem with that total is how the NA is regarded. Major League Baseball does not consider it a major league, leaving Anson with only his 1880 RBI accumulated during his time in the NL. Those 1880 RBI would leave Anson 12th all time, sandwiched between Willie Mays and Mel Ott.

Cap Anson did collect over 2000 RBI in his professional career. Nonetheless, his inclusion on this list is still a matter of controversy.

Babe Ruth

Interestingly, Babe Ruth is the only left handed hitter in MLB history to reach the 2000 RBI platform.

Perhaps it is not that much of a surprise. He had completely changed the game, making home runs more than just a fluke occurrence. He would annihilate the single season home run record, and then become the first player in MLB history to reach the 200, 300, 400, 500, 600, and 700 home run plateaus.

Ruth became the second member of the 2000 RBI club in 1932. In doing so, he became the youngest member of that group, and the player to reach that milestone the fastest, notching his 2000th RBI in just 2196 games. He would pass Anson a year later, the last season that he would drive in over 100 runs.

All told, Ruth had 13 seasons of over 100 RBI, leading the league five times. One of the best run producers the game had seen, Ruth had six seasons where he drove in over 150 runs. He retired with the RBI record, driving in 2214 runs in his illustrious career.

Babe Ruth is remembered for his prodigious power and the way he has helped shape the modern game. He was also, not surprisingly, one of the great run producers in the history of the game.

Hank Aaron

Not only did Hank Aaron break Babe Ruth’s home run record, but he ended up surpassing the Bambino on the all time RBI list as well.

It was, perhaps, inevitable. He was a remarkably consistent hitter, and while he never had that one standout season, had 15 seasons with at least 30 home runs. That led to Aaron being an incredible run producer as well, as he had 11 years with over 100 RBI, and led the league four times.

That chase for Ruth’s home run record was a key moment in not just MLB history, but in American culture. He had been dogged by death threats and racism, the majority of the mail he received coming from racists and threatening his life. Ultimately, Aaron persevered, surpassing Ruth as the Home Run King.

Aaron took over as the all time RBI leader in 1975, setting the record as a part of the Milwaukee Brewers. As his career began in Milwaukee, albeit with the Braves, it was sort of fitting that he would break the record as part of another franchise from that city. His 2000th RBI came as a member of the Braves however, occurring during the 1972 season.

Hank Aaron once said that he never wanted baseball fans to forget Babe Ruth, he just wanted fans to remember him. That will not be a problem.

Alex Rodriguez

Yes, Alex Rodriguez was the fourth player in MLB history to reach the 2000 RBI plateau, but his place in the pantheon of the game is questionable.

More from Call to the Pen

• Philadelphia Phillies, ready for a stretch run, bomb St. Louis Cardinals
• Philadelphia Phillies: The 4 players on the franchise’s Mount Rushmore
• Boston Red Sox fans should be upset over Mookie Betts’ comment
• Analyzing the Boston Red Sox trade for Dave Henderson and Spike Owen
• 2023 MLB postseason likely to have a strange look without Yankees, Red Sox, Cardinals

For a time, Rodriguez was one of the greatest hitters in the game, an incredible power threat at short and third. He led the league in home runs five times, and had 14 years with over 100 RBI. He collected his 2000th RBI in 2015, and surpassed Anson for third place a year later.

The problem with Rodriguez’ accomplishments is that they are considered tainted. Rodriguez missed the entire 2014 season due to his PED usage and links to the Biogenesis scandal, and had earlier been tied to PED usage as well. He also developed a negative reputation, suing the league because of his suspension, and generally rubbing fanbases everywhere the wrong way.

In theory, reaching the 2000 RBI Club is grounds to immediately be inducted into the Hall of Fame. Ruth, Aaron, and Anson are considered amongst the greatest ever in MLB history, inner circle Hall of Famers whose credentials are beyond reproach. Rodriguez, however, has that PED suspension against him, which may keep him on the outside looking in.

The fourth player to reach the 2000 RBI milestone in MLB history, Alex Rodriguez is also the most controversial. His place in history is secure, but the narrative surrounding it is not.