New York Yankees: Predicting the 2020 starting lineup

The 2019 MLB season just ended but it feels like it’s been months. So, I’ve gone ahead and compiled a list of players that will comprise the 2020 New York Yankees lineup… according to me.

For the second time in three seasons, the New York Yankees were eliminated in game seven of the ALCS against the sign-stealing Houston Astros. Next season, they’ll be looking to finally get over the hump and break their 10-year streak of missing the World Series.

To do so, however, the Yankees will have to add a few pieces here and there to elevate the team to a slightly higher level.

Now, I’ve already declared that the key piece the team has to add is a starting pitcher, namely Gerrit Cole. However, given injuries to Aaron Hicks, losing players like Didi Gregorius, and parting ways with sluggers like Edwin Encarnacion, the front office will also have to look to add a bat or two.

Not only that, with Didi and Brett Gardner testing free agency and Hicks undergoing Tommy John Surgery, the Yanks could lose three players that “took 60 percent of the Yankees’ lefty plate appearances in 2019,” according to Joel Sherman of The New York Post. Therefore, the team is in desperate need of a left-handed hitter.

So, I’ve gone ahead and predicted that the team will add a switch-hitting or left-handed hitter, but you’ll have to continue reading to find out who it is. That being said, let’s put ourselves in Aaron Boone‘s shoes and take a look at the top of the lineup in 2020.

Predicting the 2020 New York Yankees Lineup

Francisco Lindor, SS

Given how desperately the Yankees are for a left-handed bat, if the team chooses not to re-sign Didi Gregorius, they will aggressively pursue another lefty or switch-hitting shortstop.

Now, since the market for shortstops is sparse, Didi could possibly get more than what the Yanks are willing to give him and walk. This opens up the possibility for a dream come true for Yankees fans, trading for Francisco Lindor.k

While the chances of this happening are pretty slim, dreaming never killed anyone. Though I predicted in a previous piece that the Yanks would re-sign Gregorius, I am now here to tell you that the tides have shifted and the Bronx Bombers will indeed trade for Mr. Smile, the leadoff hitter.

Aaron Judge, OF

Many folks have a problem with Aaron Judge, a prominent power hitter hitting so high in the lineup. Traditionally, a guy of Judge’s stature would hit third or clean-up. Not in New York, and I fully agree with the move.

Despite all the strikeouts, Judge is an on-base machine. Therefore, the higher he hits in the lineup, the more opportunities this stacked lineup has to score runs. So, in 2020, Judge will remain the team’s number two hitter.

DJ LeMahieu, 1B

Though the New York Yankees super-utility infielder is not an AL MVP finalist this year, there is no doubt that he was by far the best player on the team. Playing multiple positions at an elite level, LeMahieu still managed to have one of his best offensive seasons in 2019.

What’s more, while Greg Bird couldn’t healthy and Luke Voit took a step back this season, DJ LeMahieu took over first base and mastered the position in a matter of days. In 2020, with the addition of Lindor and Gleyber Torres remaining at second, LeMahieu will be the team’s full-time first baseman.

Predicting the 2020 New York Yankees Lineup

Mike Tauchman, OF

More from Call to the Pen

• Philadelphia Phillies, ready for a stretch run, bomb St. Louis Cardinals
• Philadelphia Phillies: The 4 players on the franchise’s Mount Rushmore
• Boston Red Sox fans should be upset over Mookie Betts’ comment
• Analyzing the Boston Red Sox trade for Dave Henderson and Spike Owen
• 2023 MLB postseason likely to have a strange look without Yankees, Red Sox, Cardinals

With Aaron Hicks having Tommy John surgery, the New York Yankees are short an outfielder. Sure, there are options in the minors in Clint Frazier and Estevan Florial. However, one or both of those players will be included in the deal for Lindor (fingers crossed).

This leaves us with Mike Tauchman, who stepped in and absolutely raked this season. What’s more, Tauchman showed that he can play the outfield at an elite level. If Tauch can continue his production in 2019, he may just win an outfield job over full time.

Gio Urshela, 3B

You’re probably wondering what happened to the 2018 AL Rookie of the Year runner-up Miguel Andujar. Well, he too will be included in the deal for Lindor (fingers really crossed). This opens up third base for Gio Urshela, who stepped into the role and not only showed he can hit on par with Andujar, but he can also field way better than him too.

Brett Gardner, OF

Finally, Gardy will return for a final season with the Yankees in 2020. At first, he’ll man center field, but when Hicks returns he will be relegated to a bench player. Hopefully, the team can enable Gardy to exit the game the way he came in, with a World Series victory.