MLB Hall of Fame: Breaking down the 2020 ballot

The 2020 MLB Hall of Fame ballot was announced back in November. This year has one certain first ballot Hall of Famer, and some truly interesting players.

As we wait for winter to end, and the sounds of Spring Training to start up once more, there are certain moments that we can all look forward to. One of those is the annual release of the MLB Hall of Fame ballot, a moment in time where, for the most part, one or more players will officially become a part of baseball immortality.

While some ballots have little drama, that is not the case this year. We all know that Derek Jeter will be a first ballot Hall of Famer – the only question is whether or not he joins former teammate Mariano Rivera as the only players in the history of the game to be named on every ballot. But that does not mean that there are not other interesting story lines.

Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, two players forever linked due to PED allegations, are both entering their eighth year on the ballot. Both players have been above the 50% mark, but have yet to crack 60% and really make a run at Cooperstown. Is this the year? Then there is Curt Schilling, a relatively borderline case statistically, whose post career antics and beliefs have made him suffer at the ballot. Will he get traction this time, and find his way to upstate New York?

Let us take a look at this year’s MLB Hall of Fame ballot, and check out each of the 32 players listed.

Bobby Abreu – first year on ballot

Bobby Abreu has a better case for the MLB Hall of Fame than one may have thought.

A true five tool player in his prime, Abreu was a star with the Phillies. However, he was with the franchise prior to their run of postseason success, a great player on teams that just were not good enough to play in October. While he was a part of three postseasons, he seemingly just missed those runs of sustained success.

Perhaps that is why Abreu never had the accolades his career deserved. He was a part of just two All Star Games, and won a Gold Glove in 2005. Overall in his career, he posted a .291/.392/.475 batting line, hitting 288 homers and stealing exactly 400 bases. Abreu ranks in the top 25 all time in doubles, walks, and putouts and assists in right.

Yet, his career was generally overlooked during his career. He was a solid overall player, but that may not matter when it comes to the voters. That lack of recognition, as he was overshadowed throughout his career, may cause issues as he looks to remain on the ballot. As good as his overall numbers may be, Abreu is not a lock to reach the 5% threshold to remain on the ballot.

Bobby Abreu was the type of player any team would have wanted. But that does not mean that he has a realistic chance at the MLB Hall of Fame.

Josh Beckett – first year on ballot

A one time top prospect, Josh Beckett is now best remembered for his part in the ‘Chicken and Beer’ controversy that led to his unceremonious departure from the Red Sox as part of a massive salary dump.

After being selected with the second overall pick in the 1999 MLB Draft, Beckett was expected to be a star for the Marlins. He rocketed through their system, making his major league debut just two years later. He appeared ready to fulfill that destiny when he was named the 2003 World Series MVP, but was never quite able to put everything together.

That is not to say that Beckett did not have his moments of success. A three time All Star, he won 15 or more games four times, leading the American League with 20 victories in 2007. Overall, he posted a 138-106 record, with a 3.88 ERA and a 1.232 WHiP. In his 2051 innings, he struck out 1901 batters while issuing 629 walks.

However, his career ended prematurely. Neck and hip issues led to his making just 28 appearances over his final two seasons, with that hip forcing him into retirement. His career, as respectable as it was, had to be considered a disappointment, given the lofty expectations of his draft spot and his talent. He just was never able to get that talent to translate to the mound.

Josh Beckett has made his way to the MLB Hall of Fame ballot. Chances are, this will be his only appearance.

Heath Bell – first year on ballot

For a time, Heath Bell was one of the best closers in the game. And then, he fell off a cliff.

A respectable setup man, Bell took over as the Padres closer when future Hall of Famer Trevor Hoffman moved over to the Brewers. In his three seasons as San Diego’s closer, the team did not miss a beat, as Bell proved to be a worthy replacement. However, when he was traded to the Marlins at the conclusion of the 2012 campaign, his career fell apart.

A three time All Star, Bell saved over 40 games in each of his three seasons as the Padres closer, leading the league with 42 saves in 2009. During his career, he posted a 3.49 ERA and a 1.269 WHiP, notching 168 saves. In his 628.2 innings, Bell struck out 637 batters while issuing 214 walks.

Every year, there are players who make their one appearance on the MLB Hall of Fame ballot and fail to receive a vote. Some of those players seem to be questionable choices to even be included for consideration. Bell is one of those players – a pitcher who was briefly a star caliber closer, but one whose career could really be summed up in those three seasons.

Heath Bell had a solid run, but it will not be enough for the former Padres closer to join Hoffman in the MLB Hall of Fame.

Barry Bonds – eighth year on ballot (59.1% in 2019)

It is past time for Barry Bonds to be a part of the MLB Hall of Fame.

Yes, we all know the arguments against – he is one of the poster boys for the PED Era, after all. While he never tested positive for steroids, his involvement with the BALCO Scandal, and subsequent trial on perjury charges, have tainted his reputation. Add in the way that his body changed during his career, and it is easy to draw conclusions.

Nonetheless, Bonds holds a unique place in the history of the game. One of the eight players in MLB history to hit 300 homers and steal 300 bases in their career, Bonds is also the only member of the 400-400 and 500-500 club. A 14 time All Star, he won seven MVP awards, eight Gold Gloves, and two batting titles. Bonds produced a lifetime .298/.444/.607 batting line, hitting 762 homers and stealing 514 bases. He is the all time leader in home runs and walks, and holds the single season record with 73 homers.

Of course, there are those who will say that those numbers are tainted by PED usage. The problem is that during the time when Bonds was putting those numbers up, PED use was rampant in the game. The MLB Hall of Fame has honored players who were known to cheat by scuffing the ball or using the spitter. And, they have a known PED user that has been inducted as well in Pud Galvin.

It is time to give Barry Bonds his due, although that is not likely to happen this year.

Eric Chavez – first year on ballot

If Eric Chavez had been able to remain healthy, he could have ended up in Cooperstown.

At a time that the Oakland A’s were sending away most players making a considerable sum, Chavez was the one they kept. It was easy to see why – he was a power hitting third baseman who played incredible defense. Born in Los Angeles, he was a local kid who made good, the perfect player to be the face of the franchise.

Chavez certainly had a solid career. Although he was never an All Star, he still made his mark on the game. He was a six time Gold Glove winner, and won the Silver Slugger award in 2002. Chavez produced a lifetime .268/.342/.475 batting line, hitting 260 homers and 318 doubles. He hit over 25 homers in six consecutive seasons, establishing himself as one of the premier third baseman of the time.

The problem was that he was unable to stay healthy. Back issues ruined what should have been the prime of his career, as he played in a total of 154 games between the ages of 29 and 32. The first half of his career had him on a path to superstardom, but he was unable to reach those same heights.

Eric Chavez began his career as the type of player that could have ended up in the MLB Hall of Fame. Sadly, injuries ended his chance at immortality.

Roger Clemens – eighth year on ballot (59.5% in 2019)

If Barry Bonds is considered one of the poster boys for the PED Era, then Roger Clemens is another.

Just like Bonds, Clemens never failed a PED test. And, like Bonds again, he was a part of the Mitchell Report. Clemens ended up testifying in front of the U.S. House of Representatives against his former trainer Brian McNamee, and former teammate Andy Pettitte, who claimed that Clemens told him he used PEDs. He also faced perjury charges, but was eventually acquitted.

Those allegations overshadowed what was a stellar career. Clemens was an 11 time All Star, and won the pitching Triple Crown twice. A seven time Cy Young winner, he was also named the 1986 AL and All Star Game MVPs. In his career, he posted a 354-184 record, along with a 3.12 ERA and a 1.173 WHiP. Over his 4916.2 innings, he struck out 4672 batters while issuing 1580 walks.

While there is no proof that Clemens used PEDs, circumstantial evidence is damning. He had four mediocre years at the end of his time with the Red Sox, then suddenly became a star again with the Blue Jays. Clemens got better in his late 30s and into his 40s, one of the best pitchers in the game. Yet, as with Bonds, it was the Steroid Era – even if he was doing something, he was still one of the best there was.

Roger Clemens is likely to end up in the MLB Hall of Fame. It just may take until his final year on the ballot before he and Bonds are inducted together.

Adam Dunn – first year on ballot

No player symbolized the Three True Outcome concept quite like Adam Dunn.

In fact, Dunn may well be the player that truly became that ideal. In just under 50% of his plate appearances (49.9279% to be exact) he either hit a home run, walked, or struck out. It was fascinating to watch when he was at the plate.

Even with his rather interesting profile, Dunn had a solid career. A two time All Star, he posted a lifetime .237/.364/.490 batting line, hitting 462 home runs and 334 doubles. Dunn reached the 40 home run plateau six times, but never led the league in that category. He led the league in walks twice and strikeouts four times as well, ranking 43rd in walks and third all time in strikeouts.

While that is an impressive dedication to his standing as the top Three True Outcome player, it is really not enough to warrant inclusion into the MLB Hall of Fame. Dunn certainly was a respectable power hitter, but he was dreadful defensively and was a very one dimensional player. That road, while it led to over $112 million in salary, will not end in Cooperstown.

Adam Dunn had a very specific niche in the majors. And he played his part perfectly.

Chone Figgins – first year on ballot

Chone Figgins was a solid utility player during his time with the Angels. Once he headed to the Pacific Northwest, that came to an end.

One could hardly fault Figgins. The Mariners offered the speedy utility man a four year deal worth $35 million after the 2010 season, which was more than enough to entice him to change teams. Unfortunately, he never lived up to that contract, being released three years into the deal. After not appearing in the majors at all in 2013, he resurfaced briefly with the Dodgers, appearing in 38 games before his career was over.

Unfortunately, that stint in Seattle overshadows Figgins’ overall career. An All Star in 2009, he posted a lifetime .276/.349/.363 batting line, hitting 118 doubles and stealing 341 bases. He stole over 40 bases five times, leading the AL in 2004 with 62 steals. Figgins also led the league in walks in 2009, drawing 101 free passes as he finished tenth in the MVP vote.

Ultimately, Figgins was a valuable major league player during his heyday with the Angels. He had three different primary positions, performing decently with the glove. His speed and ability to get on base made him a dangerous leadoff hitter. And that is where it ends – Figgins was a solid player who filled a number of holes on the Angels.

That made Chone Figgins a very good major league asset. That does not mean that he will be enshrined in the MLB Hall of Fame.

Jason Giambi – first year on ballot

In reality, Jason Giambi‘s career can be broken down into two halves.

Prior to his injuries in 2004, Giambi was an all around force at first. He was a perrenial threat to hit over .300 with over 40 home runs, while his impressive batting eye consistently kept him amongst the league leaders in walks. Then, after injuries and an admission of PED usage, he became more of a three true outcome slugger – the power and batting eye were there, but he only batted over .250 three times in the final 11 years of his career.

Overall, Giambi had a strong resume. He was a five time All Star, and took home the 2000 AL MVP award. A two time Silver Slugger, he posted a lifetime .277/.399/.516 batting line, hitting 405 doubles and 440 homers. Giambi led the league in walks four times, and in on base percentage on three occasions.

However, there is that PED admission. Even asking for forgiveness from the voters has not manifested in a strong showing; just ask Mark McGwire and Andy Pettitte (who we will look at later). Giambi was a key part of the A’s success at the beginning of the century, and the Yankees run through the mid 2000s, but that is not likely enough to keep him on the ballot beyond this year.

Jason Giambi was a tale of two halves. The first half of his career was worthy of being inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame. The same could not be said for the second.

Todd Helton – second year on ballot (16.5% in 2019)

Todd Helton went from being Peyton Manning’s backup in college to having a stellar major league career.

Helton was a remarkably consistent player, failling to hit over .300 only five times in his 17 years in the majors. He was one of the top run producers in the NL, a true power threat even outside the launching pad known as Coors Field. Helton was also a remarkable first baseman, ranking in the top three all time in assists, double plays, and runs saved at first.

Yet, for his accomplishments, Helton was still relatively overlooked. He did earn a few accolades, as he was a five time All Star, won four Silver Sluggers, and three Gold Gloves. Yet, his .316/.414/.539 batting line, along with his 592 doubles, 369 homers, and 1406 RBI, do not garner the attention they deserve from the voters.

Perhaps this is due to the bias against players in Colorado. While Helton was markedly better at home than on the road, he still produced a very respectable .855 OPS away from Coors Field. That happens to be equal to the career marks of other MLB Hall of Fame candidates Jeff Kent and Scott Rolen. Helton, just from his road production, has the type of career that would generate consideration for enshrinement.

Yet, the Coors Field stigma remains. Todd Helton should remain on the ballot, but he is still being dramatically overlooked.

Raul Ibanez – first year on ballot

Over his career, Raul Ibanez was prized not just for what he could do on the diamond, but for what he meant in the locker room.

Although it took until he was already 29 years old to get a real chance in the lineup, Ibanez still put together a solid career. He was a respected run producer with power, driving in over 100 runs four times, and posting eight seasons with 20 or more homers. As his career continued, he was a valued locker room presence, a calming veteran who was essentially an additional coach on the bench and in the lineup.

Despite that late start, Ibanez had a solid career. He was an All Star in 2009 with the Phillies, and received MVP votes three times. Ibanez produced a .272/.335/.465 batting line, hitting 424 doubles and 305 homers. Yet, that stat line does not do him justice, as he was far more valuable than the numbers would indicate.

Unfortunately, intangibles can only get a candidate so far. While Ibanez was respected throughout the game, and is seemingly bound to get a major league managerial job if he wants, he just does not have the performance needed to be enshrined in Cooperstown. At the end of the day, he was a very good player, but not at a level that will result in immortality.

Raul Ibanez may get a few votes. But it will not be enough for a second year on the MLB Hall of Fame ballot.

Derek Jeter – first year on ballot

The question is not if Derek Jeter will be inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame, but rather if he will be the second player to receive 100% of the vote.

It is easy to see why that would be the case. Jeter was everything a team could ask for. He was considered the epitome of class, the captain of the historic Yankees, the biggest part of the Core Four. Jeter was a star on the biggest stage, a clutch performer who helped guide the franchise to five World Series victories, earning the World Series MVP award in 2000.

It is seemingly impossible to list his accolades. Jeter was a 14 time All Star, won the Rookie of the Year award in 1996, and won five Sliver Slugger awards and five Gold Gloves. During his career, he produced a .310/.377/.440 batting line, hitting 544 doubles, 260 homers, and stealing 358 bases. His 3465 hits rank sixth all time in MLB history, and he produced eight seasons with over 200 hits.

Yes, there are “blemishes” to Jeter’s resume if one wants to nitpick. He never won a regular season MVP award, but he did finish in the top ten eight times. And there are questions about how many of his Gold Glove awards were deserved. But all of that is irrelevant – Jeter is one of the greatest shortstops in the history of the game, arguably right there with Honus Wagner for the title.

We’ll be seeing Derek Jeter in Cooperstown this coming summer. Chances are, he will join teammate Mariano Rivera in getting every possible vote.

Andruw Jones – third year on ballot (7.5% in 2019)

While Andruw Jones had a solid career with the bat, his MLB Hall of Fame case truly comes down to how much one valued his defense.

Quite simply, there has been no one like Jones that has played center field in MLB history. Over his career, he won ten consecutive Gold Gloves, emerging as a human highlight reel in center for the Braves. His 230 runs saved in center are the best in MLB history, and the 253 runs he saved over his career ranks second, trailing only Brooks Robinson.

Jones was also handy with the bat during his prime. A true five tool player, Jones was a five time All Star and finished second in the 2005 NL MVP vote. Over his career, he posted a .254/.337/.486 batting line, hitting 414 homers, 383 doubles, and stealing 152 bases. Those numbers were depressed after he left the Braves, when his career fell off a cliff as his weight ballooned.

The offense alone would not be enough to enshrine Jones. Yet, there have been plenty of players whose induction has come mainly due to their ability on defense. The likes of Ozzie Smith, Bill Mazeroski, and Ray Schalk, amongst others, are not in the Hall for their ability to hit. If they can be inducted, there is room for Jones as well.

Andruw Jones was, quite simply, one of the greatest defensive players in the history of the game. Add in his respectable production with the bat, and he deserves a longer look for the MLB Hall of Fame.

Jeff Kent – seventh year on ballot (18.1% in 2019)

On the opposite side of the coin from Andruw Jones, there is Jeff Kent.

It took a while for Kent to get a chance, mainly because it took a while for teams to find a place for him in the lineup. After bouncing around the infield, he eventually settled in at second base. However, it took his being traded to the San Francisco Giants for Kent to break out as a star at 29 years old.

Despite that late start to his career, Kent established himself as arguably the greatest offensive second baseman in MLB history. He was a five time All Star, and won the 2000 NL MVP award while finishing in the top ten in three other seasons. Overall, Kent produced a .290/.356/.500 batting line with 377 homers, 560 doubles, and 1518 RBI. He was a rarity – a true middle of the order bat who also happened to play at second base.

There are several reasons as to why Kent’s candidacy has yet to gain traction. He has been linked to the PED scandals although there has not been any evidence of his own usage. Kent also had a prickly relationship with the media at best, hardly making any of the voters rush out to check the box next to his name on the ballot.

Jeff Kent deserves to be in the MLB Hall of Fame. It just might take a long time for him to get there.

Paul Konerko – first year on ballot

A very good player for the White Sox, Paul Konerko has a reasonable case for the MLB Hall of Fame.

It took a bit for Konerko to find a home. A former top prospect with the Dodgers, he was traded to the Reds for Jeff Shaw. Just a few months later, he landed in Chicago, dealt to the South Side for Mike Cameron. There, he was able to blossom and become a beloved member of the White Sox.

He certainly had a respectable career. Konerko was a six time All Star, and the MVP of the 2005 ALCS. He finished in the top ten of the MVP vote twice, and had seven seasons where he hit over 30 homers. Overall, he produced a .279/.354/.486 batting line, hitting 410 doubles and 439 homers.

While those are certainly respectable numbers, they just are not good enough for enshrinement. Konerko also does not have any of the other possible boosts – defensively, he cost the White Sox 37 runs at first, and his 27.7 WAR is tied for 23rd out of the 32 candidates on the ballot. He may get a vote or five, but Konerko is likely done after this year.

Paul Konerko had a very nice career. It just was not a Hall of Fame caliber one.

Cliff Lee – first year on ballot

For a time, Cliff Lee was one of the best pitchers in baseball.

The staff ace of the Indians and the Phillies, he had an impressive run from 2008 through 2013. However, injuries hampered his career before and after that span, keeping him from truly fulfilling his potential. Those injuries essentially ended his career, as he missed the entire 2015 campaign after suffering a partial tear in the flexor tendon of his left elbow. After failing to generate any interest in free agency the following year, retirement was forced upon Lee.

He certainly had a solid career. Lee was a four time All Star, and won the 2008 AL Cy Young award. He won led the league in wins and ERA that season, putting together a truly dominant year. During his 13 years in the majors, Lee posted a 143-91 record, with a 3.52 ERA and a 1.196 WHiP. Over his 2156.2 innings, Lee struck out 1824 batters while issuing only 464 walks.

During his six year run of dominance, Lee was one of the best pitchers in the game. He was a workhorse, consistently leading his teams to the postseason and posting strong results. The problem is that his peak was far too short, and he was unable to remain on the mound long enough to build upon his resume.

Cliff Lee was once one of the best pitchers in the majors. But that is not enough for enshrinement.

Carlos Pena – first year on ballot

It took a long time for Carlos Pena to really blossom into the power hitting threat he was expected to be.

A one time top prospect in the Rangers system, Pena bounced around the majors for nearly a decade. He did show some promise with the Tigers, but it was not until he signed with the Tampa Bay Rays that he became a star. Suddenly, Pena was able to fulfill his potential, turning into the middle of the order bat he was expected to be.

Understandably, Pena will be remembered for that run with the Rays. While he was only named to one All Star Game, he finished ninth in the AL MVP vote twice, won the 2008 Gold Glove at first, and was a Silver Slugger in 2007. The 2009 AL home run leader, Pena posted an overall .232/.346/.462 batting line, hitting 286 homers.

However, those first four years with the Rays were really the culmination of his career. Pena posted a career 25.1 WAR, and was worth 17.5 WAR from 2007 through 2010. Over the other ten years in his career, he was barely above replacement level.

Just the fact that Carlos Pena is on this year’s MLB Hall of Fame ballot is a testament to how well he performed during that four year run in Tampa Bay. In all likelihood, that will not be enough to garner any votes.

Brad Penny – first year on ballot

At least Brad Penny can say he was on the MLB Hall of Fame ballot.

A one time top prospect for the Marlins, he was expected to form the core of the rotation along with A.J. Burnett and Josh Beckett. To a degree, the trio fulfilled expectations, as they were a key part of the 2003 World Series winning squad. Yet, Penny, like the others, never really became the pitcher he was expected to be.

He did have his moments. Penny was a two time All Star, both appearances coming with the Dodgers. In those two seasons, he led the league in wins (2005) and winning percentage (2006). Overall, he posted a lifetime 121-101 record, along with a 4.29 ERA and a 1.376 WHiP. In his 1925 innings, he struck out 1273 batters while issuing 619 walks.

Being a part of the ballot may well be his third greatest accomplishment on the diamond. Penny won two games in the 2003 World Series, and also dated known baseball player collector Alyssa Milano. As impressive as that is, those accomplishments will not help his case for induction.

At least Brad Penny can say he was on the MLB Hall of Fame ballot. He will not be there next year.

Andy Pettitte – second year on ballot (9.9% in 2019)

Despite a fairly strong case for the MLB Hall of Fame, Andy Pettitte did not receive any traction last year.

A part of the Yankees Core Four, Pettitte was a key part of their five most recent World Series titles. Although he followed Roger Clemens to the Astros, Pettitte returned home, cementing his legacy as one of the best pitchers in franchise history. He seemed to be another perfect representation of the pinstripes.

Pettitte had a solid, albeit somewhat underrated, career. He was only named to the All Star Game three times despite earning Cy Young votes in five seasons and winning 15 or more games eight times. Overall, the 2001 ALCS MVP posted a 256-153 record, along with a 3.85 ERA and a 1.351 WHiP. In his 3316 innings, he struck out 2448 batters while issuing 1031 walks.

The problem is that Pettitte has the giant PED decal attached to his candidacy. Unlike some of the others, he admitted to his usage, and even threw Clemens under the bus. However, just like with Mark McGwire, honesty has not helped his cause. It is doubtful that he will ever get the due his career deserves.

Andy Pettitte is a borderline candidate for the MLB Hall of Fame. However, his PED usage almost ensures that he will not be inducted.

J.J. Putz – first year on ballot

J.J. Putz was seemingly feast or famine as a reliever.

There were times when Putz was one of the best closers in the game, a force in the ninth inning that could get anyone out. Then, at other times, Putz was napalm on the mound, the relief equivalent of pouring petrol on a bonfire. There really was not an in between when it came to Putz.

Yet, when his career was over, Putz had respectable enough numbers. An All Star in 2007, he posted a 3.08 ERA and a 1.152 WHiP, notching 189 saves. While he had four seasons with over 30 saves, Putz also had seven years where he failed to reach double digits in the category. Putz struck out 599 batters with 184 walks in his 566.2 innings.

That inconsistency definitely hurt Putz throughout his career. Despite having those occasionally dominant years, he was consistently overlooked for the MidSummer Classic. Likewise, he could not hold the closer job long enough to really build a resume worthy of the MLB Hall of Fame.

At times, J.J. Putz would dominate. But those times were not frequent enough to warrant induction in Cooperstown.

Manny Ramirez – fourth year on ballot (22.8% in 2019)

If a player that has actually been suspended for PEDs ends up in the MLB Hall of Fame, it may be Manny Ramirez.

He was an adventure on the diamond, disappearing into the Green Monster to use the bathroom, and cutting off a throw from his fellow outfielder. Ramirez had a prickly personality, getting into a fight with a clubhouse attendant. But he was also a lovable figure, a goofy hitting savant that was fortunate that he had the ability to pulverize the baseball.

Ramirez was certainly a well regarded player. He was a 12 time All Star and a nine time Silver Slugger, finishing in the top ten of the MVP vote nine times. Overall, he posted a stellar .312/.411/.585 batting line, hitting 555 homers and 547 doubles. Based on his production, he belongs in the MLB Hall of Fame.

The problem is that Ramirez was suspended for PED usage twice. While one could claim that the initial failed test was an accident or the result of a tainted supplement, the stain was already there. His second failed test put his entire legacy in doubt, turning what once seemed to be a slam dunk Hall of Fame case into a major question mark. Unsurprisingly, he has not gained any traction towards induction, sitting between 22% and 24% in each of his previous three years on the ballot.

Chances are, 2020 will mark a fourth year where Manny Ramirez has a similar vote total. His legacy has been irrevocably tarnished by his PED usage.

Brian Roberts – first year on ballot

It is not a surprise that Brian Roberts is on the MLB Hall of Fame ballot. However, it is a reminder of what his career could have been.

Roberts had been a mainstay in the Orioles lineup, a second baseman with plenty of doubles power and excellent speed. In his last healthy season in 2009, he led the league in doubles while finishing third in runs scored and eighth in stolen bases. However, in his final five seasons, Roberts appeared in a total of 283 games, playing more than half a season just once, as he was bothered by a myriad of injuries, including a concussion that he gave himself when he hit himself in the head with his bat in frustration following a strikeout.

Those injuries ruined what could have been an even better career for Roberts. As it was, he still led the league in doubles twice and steals once, having seven consecutive seasons with over 20 steals. Overall, he produced a .276/.347/.409 batting line, hitting 367 doubles, 97 homers, and stealing 285 bases.

The vast majority of that production came over a seven year span, where Roberts was one of the best infielders in the game. Unfortunately, he did little else in his other seven years, with injuries ruining his productivity, and ultimately, his career. Those injuries essentially ended any chance he had at being inducted.

Brian Roberts is another candidate for the Hall of Very Good, but just did not have enough longevity for the MLB Hall of Fame.

Scott Rolen – third year on ballot (17.2% in 2019)

Simply stated, Scott Rolen was one of the best third basemen in the history of the game.

Rolen was a solid all around player, a power hitting third baseman who also had excellent speed on the basepaths. He was brilliant defensively, winning eight Gold Glove awards while ranking sixth in MLB history with 140 runs saved at the hot corner. While his glove may have been his greatest tool, his overall ability places him amongst the best players to ever line up at third.

It is hard to argue with his production and resume. The 1997 NL Rookie of the Year, Rolen was a seven time All Star, and finished as high as fourth in the 2006 NL MVP vote. Overall, he posted a .281/.364/.490 batting line, hitting 316 homers and 517 doubles while stealing 118 bases.

During his career, Rolen was overshadowed by other top third basemen, from Chipper Jones to Alex Rodriguez when he made the move to the hot corner. That lack of recognition reflected in his vote totals, as his 17.2% last year is laughable. However, he did gain nearly 7% of the vote last year on a solid ballot. With this one containing just one sure fire Hall of Famer, that percentage should rise once more.

Scott Rolen has a lot of ground to make up to be inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame, but his resume and production make him a more than worthy candidate.

Curt Schilling – eighth year on ballot (60.9% in 2019)

If only Curt Schilling could shut his mouth, he might already be in the MLB Hall of Fame.

He certainly did not appear to be a viable Hall of Fame candidate over the first half of his career. Aside from two solid years with the Phillies, he appeared to be a decent starter, but nothing particularly special. Then, finally healthy once he turned 30, Schilling had a strong second portion of his career, sparking a renaissance that made him a borderline candidate.

Schilling does have a respectable resume. He was a six time All Star and finished second in the Cy Young vote three times. His performance in the 2001 World Series led to his being named the co-MVP with Randy Johnson, and he took home the 1993 NLCS MVP award as well. Overall, Schilling produced a solid 216-146 record, along with a 3.46 ERA and a 1.137 WHiP. Over his 3261 innings, Schilling struck out 3116 batters while issuing just 711 walks.

That performance, and his postseason heroics, would seemingly be enough to lead to his induction. While that may eventually be the case, Schilling’s controversial commentary when it comes to politics, the press, and LGBTQ+ issues have alienated a large portion of the voting block. However, he gained some of those votes back last year, and could get ever closer in 2020.

Curt Schilling damaged his MLB Hall of Fame candidacy with his inability to keep his mouth shut. Only time will tell if that will further damage his chances this year.

Gary Sheffield – sixth year on ballot (13.6% in 2019)

A bit of a baseball vagabond, Gary Sheffield was a solid player, but never had that defining moment or franchise that he was associated with.

This was partially his own fault. Sheffield played for eight different teams over his 22 years in the majors, and had a reputation as a malcontent early in his career. Out of those teams, he only had one franchise that he was a part of for more than four years – the Marlins. Spending six seasons in Miami does not exactly capture the imagination of the voters.

Sheffield does, however, have a strong statistical resume. He was a nine time All Star and won five Silver Slugger awards, finishing in the top ten of the MVP vote six times. Overall, he produced a .292/.393/.514 batting line, hitting 509 homers and 467 doubles while stealing 253 bases. He had eight seasons with 30 or more homers and stole over 15 bases seven times.

Aside from that lack of a defining moment and his prickly personality, there are other issues surrounding Sheffield’s candidacy. He forced his way out of Milwaukee early in his career, admitting that he would not give a full effort as part of his desire to be dealt. Sheffield has also been dogged by PED allegations, although he never failed a drug test. Chances are, those reasons are why his candidacy has not gained any traction with the voters.

Gary Sheffield had a strong career. However, despite a resume that would seemingly lead to induction, he does not appear likely to be enshrined in the MLB Hall of Fame.

Alfonso Soriano – first year on ballot

Four players have hit at least 40 homers and stolen at least 40 bases in the same season. Alfonso Soriano was the last player to do so, accomplishing the feat in 2006.

Perhaps because Soriano accomplished that feat in his only season with the Nationals, or because he was considered a disappointment when he signed with the Cubs, that season tends to be overlooked. It is also possible that Soriano ends up with the lowest percentage of votes for the MLB Hall of Fame of any of the four members of that club.

Soriano may not have continued his Hall of Fame trajectory after that 2006 campaign, but he still had a solid career. The seven time All Star produced a .270/.319/.500 batting line, hitting 481 doubles and 412 homers. Soriano also stole 289 bases, coming just short of being the ninth player in the 300-300 club.

While Soriano will always have his place in baseball history, he is not likely to be enshrined in Cooperstown. That is not to say that he was not a great player in his own right, as he compares favorably to the likes of Dale Murphy and Jim Edmonds. However, his defensive issues, decline after signing in Chicago, and being named in the Mitchell Report, will all work against his candidacy.

Alfonso Soriano probably deserves to get enough votes to stay on the ballot for a year or two. He may not even get that.

Sammy Sosa – eighth year on ballot (8.5% in 2019)

Back in 1998, Sammy Sosa was one of the darlings of baseball. Those days feel like a lifetime ago.

His epic home run chase with Mark McGwire, as both players surpassed Roger Maris‘ record of 61 homers in a season, captivated a nation. Sosa would hit over 60 homers three times in four years, the first player to do so. He also, interestingly enough, is the only player to hit over 60 homers in a season and not lead the league, which happened in each of those three seasons.

Sosa had a strong career as well. He changed from being a wiry, faster outfielder into a muscle bound slugger, leading to his emergence as a superstar. Sosa was a seven time All Star and six time Silver Slugger, winning the 1998 NL MVP over McGwire. Overall, Sosa put together a .273/.344/.534 batting line, hitting 609 homers and stealing 234 bases.

There are issues with Sosa’s candidacy that go beyond the statistics. He had essentially walked out on the Cubs at the end of the 2004 season, leading to his being dumped on the Orioles prior to 2005. Sosa, like McGwire, became one of the poster children of the PED Era, although he never tested positive during his playing days. Of course, his being named in the Mitchell Report did not help matters, nor did his sudden inability to speak English during a Congressional hearing.

At one point, Sammy Sosa was being hailed as one of the players to save baseball. How quickly times can change…

Jose Valverde – first year on ballot

For a brief time, Jose Valverde was one of the best closers in the game. Then, as suddenly as he became a success, his effectiveness vanished.

Over the first four years of his career, Valverde split time as the Diamondbacks closer, sharing the role with the likes of Jorge Julio, Brian Bruney, Greg Aquino, and Matt Mantei. He finally took over as the primary closer in 2007, and established himself as one of the better relievers over the next six years.

That run of dominance allowed Valverde to put together a respectable resume. He was a three time All Star, and even finished 14th in the 2007 NL MVP vote. Valverde led the league in saves three times en route to notching 288 saves over his career, along with a 3.27 ERA and a 1.196 WHiP. Over his 630.1 innings, he struck out 692 strikeouts and 264 walks.

In order for a closer to enter the MLB Hall of Fame, they have to be transcendent, or, at the very minimum, remarkably consistent for an extremely long period of time. Valverde, as solid as he was during his six year run, did not have the longevity, nor the pure dominance, needed for induction.

Jose Valverde had an excellent run of success. However, that six year peak was not enough for enshrinement.

Omar Vizquel – third year on ballot (42.8% in 2019)

Omar Vizquel is considered to be one of the best defensive shortstops in MLB history. But he made himself more than just a defensive star.

At the beginning of his career, Vizquel was the epitome of the good glove-no bat middle infielders that were so prevalent in the 1980s and into the early 1990s. However, as the position evolved, and offensive production was demanded from short, Vizquel changed as well. While he was never a star with the bat, he did manage to be a respectable hitter, and even became one of four players in MLB history to hit a home run in four different decades.

Vizquel was a three time All Star by virtue of his improved hitting and stellar glove. Overall, he posted a .272/.336/.352 batting line, hitting 456 doubles and stealing 404 bases. He also ended his career with 2877 hits, the sixth highest total of any player that has not been inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame. He was also brilliant defensively, winning 11 Gold Glove awards and ranking fifth all time with 130 runs saved at short.

There is certainly a case for Vizquel to be enshrined. The likes of Ozzie Smith and Bill Mazeroski were inducted, in large part, for their defensive capabilities. Vizquel was every bit as valuable with the glove, and with the bat.

It may take some time for Omar Vizquel to be inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame. But it will not be a surprise if that day comes.

Billy Wagner – fifth year on ballot (16.7% in 2019)

Billy Wagner had an excellent career, but it was overshadowed by his postseason struggles.

After a solid rookie season as one of the Astros setup men, Wagner took over as Houston’s closer in 1997. From there, he established himself as one of the top closers in MLB history, despite having to battle back from several injuries, including Tommy John surgery. Nonetheless, Wagner was a force in the bullpen until he retired following the 2010 campaign.

A four time All Star, Wagner never led the league in saves during his career. Despite that, his 422 lifetime saves rank sixth in MLB history. He saved at least 30 games nine times in his career, showcasing his longevity in the role. Wagner posted a 2.31 ERA and a 0.998 WHiP, his 187 ERA+ ranking second all time amongst pitchers with at least 900 innings. In his 903 innings, he struck out 1196 batters while issuing 300 walks.

For all of his regular season success, Wagner struggled in October. In his 11.2 playoff innings, he posted a 10.03 ERA and a 1.971 WHiP. Wagner was also overshadowed during his career by the likes of Mariano Rivera and Trevor Hoffman, making it difficult for his success in the regular season to get the attention it deserved.

Billy Wagner may well be the best closer that has not been inducted in the MLB Hall of Fame. He has a long way to go for induction, but if he can have a strong surge up the voting ladder, he may get there in time.

Larry Walker – tenth year on ballot (54.6% in 2019)

If Larry Walker is going to be inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame by the BBWAA, it will have to happen this year.

More from Call to the Pen

• Philadelphia Phillies, ready for a stretch run, bomb St. Louis Cardinals
• Philadelphia Phillies: The 4 players on the franchise’s Mount Rushmore
• Boston Red Sox fans should be upset over Mookie Betts’ comment
• Analyzing the Boston Red Sox trade for Dave Henderson and Spike Owen
• 2023 MLB postseason likely to have a strange look without Yankees, Red Sox, Cardinals

Walker is starting to trend in the right direction as voters recognize his solid all around game. He was a true five tool player, an excellent power and speed threat with a brilliant glove and a howitzer of an arm. Yet, as recently as 2014, he barely received over 10% of the vote.

It is difficult to understand why when looking at his accomplishments. Walker was a five time All Star, and won the 1997 NL MVP award. He also won seven Gold Glove awards, and was a three time Silver Slugger. The three time batting champion posted a lifetime .313/.400/.565 batting line, hitting 383 homers and 471 doubles while steaking 230 bases.

There is a caveat when it comes to Walker’s production. Casual fans, and even some voters, look at his career numbers and imagine that they were inflated due to playing for the Rockies for ten years. Likewise, the early part of his career came in the relative anonymity of Montreal, making it easy to overlook his accomplishments. However, given his all around game, Walker deserves far more consideration for the MLB Hall of Fame.

It is now or never when it comes to the writers inducting Larry Walker into the MLB Hall of Fame. While he has received a lot more consideration over the past few years, one has to wonder if it will be enough.