Philadelphia Phillies: How many things actually must work in 2020?

Haseley produces the winning run, but will critical fans see him as more than a reserve outfielder? Photo by Nicole Fridling/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images.
Haseley produces the winning run, but will critical fans see him as more than a reserve outfielder? Photo by Nicole Fridling/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images.
1 of 2
Next
(Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images)
(Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images) /

The Philadelphia Phillies seem to have largely assembled their team for 2020. Now, what has to go right for them to compete in the NL East?

As it is now abundantly as clear as it was about a month ago that the Philadelphia Phillies are basically going into the 2020 season with what they had ten days before Christmas, the mainstream sportswriters are beginning to deliver themselves of pieces about what needs to go right, or what might go wrong, with that squad.

Jan. 13 Inquirer.com writer Matt Breen, who certainly knows this team, penned such a piece, enumerating several factors that would propel the Phillies into the playoffs.

These “high hopes,” to borrow from the late Harry Kalas, included, first, a “resurgent” Rhys Hoskins and, second, a “productive” end-of-contract, 34-year-old Jake Arrieta.

Next, Breen hopes Andrew McCutchen will have a full season of leading off for the team. And, finally, we have his fairly vague discussion under “better coaching” and the presumed arrivals of minor league third baseman Alec Bohm and minor league pitcher Spencer Howard.

Those last two guys, between them, have appeared in 69 Double-A games and have been invited to Spring Training. Both players have been college-level players before becoming pros; Bohm, as a position player, has the bulk of the 69 games between them, but the reviews of Howard’s work, which includes a Single-A no-hitter have been more glowing.

Breen seems confident both players will arrive in the Phillies clubhouse before the All-Star break, after pushing their free agency back another year with some more minor league work (which might actually be needed).

Clearly, of course, if all these matters work out well, the Phillies chances for the playoffs are in very good shape indeed. Among other things, if Howard could step into the rotation, say, in June, this would fill a hole in the rotation, specifically, the number four slot.

The number five spot should finally be awarded to one of three hurlers who have been trying to demonstrate they belong in an MLB rotation (or lately, bullpen) seemingly since the Kennedy administration, Zach Eflin, Vince Velasquez, and Nick Pivetta. What happens at number four before Howard arrives seems to involve a sketchy plan to fill-in with another of those guys, or somebody available on the cheap before or just after the team goes to Florida.

Here’s the problem with Breen’s list: At least three of those six predicted “happenings” seem more likely not to materialize than to produce fruit. You may pick your three; I know mine, and the list is topped by the notion that one of the two Double-A players really isn’t ready. Beyond that, there are a lot of known unknowns to the Philadelphia Phillies this year, chief among them the effects of new manager Joe Girardi and key coaches.

Thus, it would seem more hopes should be piled onto Matt Breen’s, suggesting other routes to the playoffs.

(Photo by Rich Schultz/Getty Images)
(Photo by Rich Schultz/Getty Images) /

What Else Has to Happen?

First, it could seriously be argued that young Adam Haseley is a key piece, if for no other reason than he is the choice for center field, a key position for which there is no apparent backup plan.

It is widely assumed that the Philadelphia Phillies will divest themselves of the recently-suspended Odubel Herrera for a “baseball reason,” and the most obvious one would be Haseley coming into Spring Training and hitting about .375 while making diving catches in the Clearwater sunshine. After that, it would be really nice if Haseley could hit about .280 out of what will likely be the seven or eight-hole in the line-up.

More from Call to the Pen

No pressure, kid.

He might well do it. Haseley will never be the greatest center fielder in the game’s history, but there’s no reason to believe he couldn’t be very, very solid, and his hitting approach – hitting line drives instead of five-run homers – is likely to drive up his rookie batting average from .266.

At a minimum, he must field the position well. It would be very nice if he didn’t let his .720 OPS last summer slide.

What else has to happen? Somebody in the bullpen has to take a serious step forward and become as close an approximation as possible to what Josh Hader was for the Brewers in 2018. I have no idea who that might be.

Finally, settle on the everyday positions for Scott Kingery and Jean Segura, and hope they hit as their careers have indicated they can for extended periods. No one really expects that someone coming to camp will beat out these two guys for second and third base; the problem is that no one really knows which guy will play where. Oh, Girardi likely has a decent idea already, but it’s time for Segura to assume the role of the puzzle piece who can fit where needed instead of forcing it on Kingery as it was as his career started.

Next. Luhnow on Astrogate: “I am not a cheater; I didn’t know.” But . . .. dark

The fact is the Philadelphia Phillies don’t need six things to go right. They need about ten, but if they get eight of them, they will be very dangerous. Oh, and in case you’re wondering, the right fielder’s performance is a given.

Next