Phillies signal paying Luxury Tax for 2020’s playoffs

Two out of three:     

Although the Phillies could dangle Bruce as a bargaining chip and free up $12 million AAV, Klentak apparently prefers the $1.65 million cost for his strongest bench piece. And the slugger could start some contests to occasionally spell left fielder Andrew McCutchen and add a third left-side hitter to the meat of the order.

Keeping Bruce is a clue to the front office’s strategy. Ergo, the higher-ups would rather pay a $3-4 million penalty than sacrifice a valuable and inexpensive asset. Bruce’s $12 million AAV could be $2.4 million of their tax, but they aren’t pursuing that option and will not if he contributes to their run production. Yes, that’s a tell!

Herrera’s situation is totally different because he hasn’t played since May 26, and the Fightins owe him $19.5 million including a buyout year. However, he’ll receive opportunities to increase his trade value for July’s deadline. But it’s Adam Haseley‘s job to lose, although Herrera could come into camp as a backup plan.

Currently, Herrera is under contract for $6.1 million AAV through 2021 with two club options. And he could earn a chance elsewhere because more franchises need center fielders than those available. Meanwhile, the New York Yankees and their fans have no problem with violators Chapman (previous) and Germán (current).

After the red pinstripes had decided to keep Bruce for 2020 and Herrera for the first half, they likely offered $7 million for Dellin Betances to outbid the New York Mets. They made a fair proposal you can’t fault. Unfortunately, the Mets had restructured Cespedes’ pact, and they overpaid Betances at $10.5 million.

What does Betances have in common with Zack Wheeler and Didi Gregorius? All three are difference-makers, and you can expect Klentak to pursue exactly the same quality in July if the team is –at least– within striking distance of the divisional leader or is making a sustained run for a Wild Card berth.