Los Angeles Dodgers: The franchise all-time bracket

The Los Angeles Dodgers have been one of MLB’s most successful franchises for eight decades. This bracket pits eight of the best teams from Brooklyn and LA.

Teams representing the Dodgers, either in Brooklyn or Los Angeles, have won six World Series championships, 24 pennants, and made 33 post-season appearances.

The franchise all-time record is a marvelous 1,160 games above .500. So an eight-team bracket pitting the Los Angeles Dodgers best against one another is bound to leave some excellent teams behind.

More from Call to the Pen

• Philadelphia Phillies, ready for a stretch run, bomb St. Louis Cardinals
• Philadelphia Phillies: The 4 players on the franchise’s Mount Rushmore
• Boston Red Sox fans should be upset over Mookie Betts’ comment
• Analyzing the Boston Red Sox trade for Dave Henderson and Spike Owen
• 2023 MLB postseason likely to have a strange look without Yankees, Red Sox, Cardinals

In selecting the fortunate eight, we will be looking at the ideal mix of criteria. The teams should represent the panoply of franchise history in both cities, they should at least touch on all the great eras of that history, and when tough calls have to be made they should favor teams that achieved the ultimate success, a World Series win.

We begin with the 100-game winners. There have been eight in franchise history, beginning with an extraordinary 1899 team and continuing through 1941, 1942, 1953, 1962, 1974, 2017 and 2019. Some, however, should be set aside.

The 1899 team was a contrived product of ‘syndicate baseball,’ a moment in time when owners were allowed to control more than one team. The 1942 and 1962 teams both failed to win pennants. In such a crowded field, the 2017 and 2019  teams are too similar to allow both in, and the 2019 team failed to reach the World Series.

That leaves 1941, 1953, 1974 and 2017 as our first four entries.

The 1963 and 1988 World Series champions represent distinct eras not yet in the field, so they must be included.

We have two spots left to fill from among some exceptional candidates, including the 1955, 1959 and 1965 and 1981 World Series winners. Of those four the best regular-season records belonged to the 1955 and 1965 Dodgers, so they fill out the bracket.

The format is identical to previous bracket challenges. Each matchup in the tournament is decided based on seven criteria. You can think of each as a ‘game,’ the winner of four games advancing. The seven criteria are:

1. Game 1: Regular season winning percentage.
2. Game 2: Post-season winning percentage
3. Game 3: Team OPS+
4. Game 4: Team ERA+
5. Game 5 (if necessary): Team WAR
6. Game 6 (if necessary: Fielding percentage above the league average for the season in question.
7. Game 7 (if necessary): Hall of Famers or likely future Hall of Famers

Los Angeles Dodgers: The All-Time Bracket

No. 1 vs. 8 seed

The 1953 Los Angeles Dodgers arguably occupied the peak of the franchise’s most glorious period. Although they lost the World Series to the New York Yankees in six games, the ‘Boys of Summer’ won 105 regular-season games.

These were the Dodgers of Jackie Robinson, Duke Snider, Gil Hodges, Roy Campanella, and Pee Wee Reese, most in their physical primes. Snider hit 42 home runs and Hodges 41. Campanella, Hodges, Snider, Robinson, and outfielder Carl Furillo all topped .300, paced by Furillo’s .344.

Campanella’s 142 RBIs led three Dodgers who were over 100.

The club effectively iced the pennant with a 13-game August winning streak.

The 1988 Dodgers pulled off one of the great post-season upsets in history, taking down both the New York Mets in the NLCS and the heavily favored Oakland Athletics in a five-game World Series. Orel Hershiser led the Dodgers with a 23-8 record that included a record late-season streak of 50 consecutive scoreless innings.

He was an obvious Cy Young Award choice. Kirk Gibson was the Dodgers’ MVP but he is best remembered for his walk-off pinch-hit home run off Dennis Eckersley in the first World Series game.

Game 1: The 1953 Dodgers’ 105-49 season works out to a .682 winning percentage. The 1988 Dodgers were 94-67, .584.

Game 2: The 1988 Dodgers had a .667 post-season record, tying this series.  The 1953 team, which lost its World Series in six games.

Game 3: The 1953 club was all about offense, as its 114 OPS+ indicates. The 1988 Dodgers had only a 90 OPS+.

Game 4: The 1988 Dodgers’ pitching superiority shows through. Their staff ERA+ was 114, nine points better than the 1953 team.

Game 5: In WAR, the 1953 Dodgers were clearly superior. They compiled a score of 54.1 that was nearly 15 points better than the 1988 club’s 39.8.

Game 6:The 1953 Dodgers were a superb fielding club whose .980 average was five points better than that season’s National League average. The 1988 Dodgers only managed a .977 average, two points below the NL average.

Result: 1953 in six games

Los Angeles Dodgers: The All-Time Bracket

No. 4 vs. 5 seed

The 1955 Los Angeles Dodgers famously won Brooklyn’s first World Series, ending decades of recurring frustration. The cast was little changed from two seasons earlier: Campanella batted .318 with 32 homers and 107 RBIs, Snider hit .314 with 42 homers and 136 RBIs, and Furillo hit .314.

On the mound, Don Newcombe went 20-5 in 31 starts with 143 strikeouts.

The 1941 Dodgers launched a tradition of winning that has extended largely unbroken to this day. That club beat St. Louis in a pulsating pennant race, needing a 100-54 record to do it. Outfielder Pete Reiser hit .341 while veteran outfielder Joe Medwick batted .318. First baseman Dolph Camilli hit 34 homers and drove in 120 runs.

Kirby Higbe and Whitlow Wyatt led the pitching staff, each winning 22 games in a combined 586 innings. Hugh Casey pitched 162 innings largely in relief, winning 14 times.

Game 1: The 1941 Dodgers had a 100-54 record, translating to a .649 winning percentage. The 1955 team went 98-55, a .641 percentage.

Game 2: The 1941 Dodgers lost the World Series in five games to the New York Yankees. The 1955 Dodgers famously beat the Yankees in seven games. This series is even through two games.

Game 3: With respect to OPS+, it’s hard to imagine a team better than the 1955 club, which produced a 109 OPS+. The 1941 team nearly matched it but stopped at 107.

Game 4: Behind Wyatt, Higbe, and Casey, the 1941 Dodgers compiled a staff 119 ERA+. The Newcombe-led 1955 Dodgers only managed  111, The series is even again through four games.

Game 5: The 1955 Dodgers generated 53.2 WAR. The 1941 team may be less recalled, but it was every bit as good. Its WAR hit 53.5, giving it a narrow victory.

Game 6: The 1941 Dodgers fielded .974, two points better than the National; League’s .972 average The 1955 team fielded .978, and that was also two points better than the league average. Carried out to extra digits, the advantage goes to the 1941 Dodgers.

Result: 1941 in six games

Los Angeles Dodgers: The All-Time Bracket

No. 2 vs. 7 seed

The 1963 Los Angeles Dodgers are remembered today for that fabulous pitching staff. Sandy Koufax delivered a virtuoso 25-5 record with a 1.88 ERA in 40 starts covering 311 innings. Don Drysdale’s record was only 19-17, but he made 42 starts and pitched 315 innings. Together they struck out 557 opponents.

The closer, Ron Perranoski, added a 16-3 record with 21 saves.

At season’s end, Koufax won both the Cy Young and MVP. In the World Series, he, Drysdale and Podres – with two-thirds of an inning’s worth of help from Perranoski – polished off the Yankees in four straight, allowing a total of just four runs and 22 hits. Thirty-seven Yankees struck out.

Offensively the Dodgers were not a great team; had they been, nobody would have ever beaten them. But they did have Maury Willis with a .302 average and 42 steals, and they did have outfielder Tommy Davis. His .326 average led the National League. Outfielder Frank Howard hit 26 home runs.

The 1974 Dodgers won 102 regular-season games before losing to Oakland in five games in the World Series. This was the famous infield of Steve Garvey, Davey Lopes,  Bill Russell, and Ron Cey, which started for LA throughout the decade of the 1970s. Garvey hit .312 with 111 RBIs while left fielder Bill Buckner hit .314 and center fielder Jim Wynn drove in 108.

Andy Messersmith won 20 games against just six losses, and Don Sutton followed close behind at 19-9. But the pitching story was Mike Marshall, who made 106 relief appearances and worked 208 innings, producing a 2.42 ERA and 21 saves alongside a 15-12 record. Marshall won the Cy Young Award and finished third in MVP voting.

Game 1: The 1963 team had a 99-63 regular-season record, but that was three games worse than 1974’s 102-60.

Game 2: The 1963 team swept New York; the 1974 Dodgers lost a five-game World Series.

Game 3: Although not known for its offense, that 1963 team at least produced a decent 99 OPS+. But the 1974 Dodgers got to 112.

Game 4: During the regular season, only Koufax and Perranoski truly stood out in 1963. As a result, the team only produced a 105 staff ERA+. The 1974 Dodgers were deeper and more balanced, and their ERA+ reached 115.

Game 5: The 1974 Dodgers compiled a 52.9 WAR. Despite Koufax’s 10.7 individual WAR, the rest of the Dodgers only raised the team total to 44.8.

Result: 1974 in five games