Free agent or trade: Which market prevails for shortstops this offseason?

So, how will the offseason pan out for three very capable free agent shortstops? They’ll likely be afterthoughts to the Big Three on the trade track – assuming Lindor, Baez, and Story remain accessible. Look for the major-market clubs like the Yankees, Mets, Phillies, and Angels to fight over those three.

A few teams that may be interested in a free agent SS include the Milwaukee Brewers, Arizona Diamondbacks, and Cincinnati Reds.

Milwaukee’s offense was atrocious this season. They would be wise to cash in on a solid bat and reassign Orlando Arcia to third base or first base, two positions that hardly produced in 2020. Left-handed hitting Didi Gregorius would be a great fit, as the Brewers are heavy with right-handed bats. They could platoon Gregorius with Arcia or Luis Urias based on pitching matchups.

The Diamondbacks remain believers within the NL West. They have the money to spend on an upgrade at shortstop, and the upgrade should be Marcus Semien. His gap-to-gap power would play well at Chase Field, and the D’Backs’ lineup could use some reliability.

All three free agent shortstops would be a stellar fit for the Reds. They desperately need to improve their defense on the left side of the infield, which makes Andrelton Simmons a strong candidate. Though, their inconsistent offense could also use a disciplined bat.

Semien, Gregorius, and Simmons will all find a home before March. Simmons will likely sign a short-term contract, while Semien and Gregorius are eligible for long-term contracts. However, it’s unlikely that any of them get the money that they desire. Again, teams won’t be spending this offseason like they usually do, plus there aren’t many clubs in need of a shortstop.

The big wigs on the trade block have clouded the market for free agent shortstops. The rumors and rumblings surrounding Lindor, Baez, Story, Semien, Gregorius, and Simmons will be fascinating to follow in the coming months. Enjoy!