Miami Marlins miscalculated Starling Marte market

The Miami Marlins already had their chance to keep Starling Marte. He had wanted to remain with the Marlins as he was looking to be a part of what they are building. The Marlins wanted to keep him as well, offering a three year extension worth $30 million. Marte’s representatives counted with three years at $50 million, leading to his being sent to the A’s at the trade deadline.

Now the Marlins want Marte back. The problem is that they are going to pay a lot more than that $50 million if he is going to return to Miami.

Miami Marlins made major mistake with Starling Marte

Marte picked a perfect time to have what may be the best season of his career. He posted a 132 OPS+ with 12 homers and 27 doubles in his 526 plate appearances, stealing a major league best 47 bases. Although his defense took a step back during his time in Oakland, he is still a two time Gold Glove winner and someone who has typically been excellent in the outfield.

It certainly helps Marte’s case that the center field market is essentially barren. Mark Canha may be the second best option in center after Marte, and he is more of a corner outfielder who happens to occasionally play the position. Marte is going to get paid.

At this point, Marte is looking at a lot more than a three year contract worth $50 million. Even though he is 33 years old, it would not be surprising to see him get a longer contract, especially as he clearly is not losing a step as he gets older.

It is also clear that the Marlins completely misread his market. That offer made by Marte’s representatives just a few months ago will seem like a bargain. Yes, Jesus Luzardo is now a member of the Marlins’ organization, but is he really worth the difference in salary should Marte return?

The Miami Marlins want Starling Marte back. If he does end up returning to the organization, he will cost a lot more than he would have just a few months ago.