The Atlanta Braves have quite the quandary when it comes to Freddie Freeman. On one hand, there is no question that they would want to bring the franchise icon back, doing their best to ensure that he spends his entire career with the franchise. On the other hand, the Braves need to balance their budget as much as possible with other extensions likely on the horizon.
The financial aspect has already been in play as it comes to Freeman. The Braves reportedly offered him a five year deal worth $135 million; he countered with six at $200 million. It is a significant difference, although one that most around the league expect to be bridged at some point.
Atlanta Braves have to balance payroll against Freddie Freeman
That may not be the case. Yes, the Braves have the financial resources to handle that type of contract for Freeman while likely having another $20 to $30 million to fill out the rest of the roster. But that is the case for this season.
The issue comes down the line. An aging Freeman would be earning over $30 million a year if the Braves gave him what he is reportedly demanding. Even a six year deal worth $180 million might be more than they would want despite it being a reasonable compromise.
Freeman is not showing any signs of slowing down. He was still a key part of the lineup last year, earning an All Star berth and finishing in the top ten in the MVP vote. Although he was unable to replicate his MVP showing of 2020, his .300/.393/.503 batting line with 31 homers and 25 doubles was still impressive.
That makes the Braves’ decision all the more difficult. They will likely have another couple of seasons of excellent production before Freeman starts to tail off. But there is also the message that bringing him back would send to the players and the fans. Sometimes, the decisions need to be about more than the financial impact.
The Atlanta Braves need to balance their future payroll against what Freddie Freeman means to the organization. It should not be a hard choice.