One could understand what Michael Conforto and his representatives were thinking. The New York Mets had offered a $100 million extension prior to the 2021 season, and Conforto felt he could earn more in free agency. The same was true with the Qualifying Offer – although Conforto had struggled in 2021, it was still likely that he would receive a long term deal in free agency.
Yet, here we are. It is the end of March and Conforto remains the top free agent available. His market has failed to materialize as hoped, and as teams have found other options to fill out their outfield, his own options are dwindling.
Michael Conforto should have taken New York Mets offer
One can understand why Conforto would not have received an offer similar to the extension he turned down. He had a disappointing 2021 campaign, posting a .232/.344/.384 batting line with 14 homers and 20 doubles in his 479 plate appearances.
However, that production was still slightly above average as he posted a 101 OPS+. He has a solid track record of success prior to last year as well, a former All Star who had been a solid power bat throughout most of his career. Conforto could be a bargain for whatever team takes him on.
Right now, the problem is finding a team that can do so. Conforto’s most likely suitors are seemingly set in the outfield. Teams that have openings are not willing to spend the money it would take to bring him in. As unexpected as it may be, his market is just not there.
That makes his decision to turn down the Mets’ extension all the more glaring. They have seemingly moved on, having rebuilt their outfield while adding more star power to their roster. Their World Series aspirations have been rekindled. Conforto, meanwhile, is sitting home wondering when the phone will ring with a contract offer.
Michael Conforto turned down an extension and the Qualifying Offer from the New York Mets. He may be regretting those decisions now.