The biggest surprise and disappointment for every American League team

After two months of the season, we have started to see what or who has done well this year. Some players have been a surprise early on, with young players taking the league by storm or others coming back from poor play in previous seasons.

On the other side of the ball, we have seen players brought up as top prospects and not be productive, or even big names come in from trades or free agency and not bring the same level of play to their new teams.

There can be multiple options to apply to each of these two areas with every team. I will mention some of them if I feel it was a close race and wanted to bring attention to more than one player, but it is all just from my perspective, and you might see it differently … especially if you are a fan of a specific team and watch these players on a more regular basis.

Let me know of any other potential players who could have been included in this article in the comment section. I would love to have a conversation with anyone who reads this article about baseball.

We will start in the American League East with the biggest surprise and disappointment for every team.

Baltimore Orioles

Surprise: Austin Hays

Hays has come into the season, hitting much better than in previous years. He currently has the highest OPS+ on the team, bumping it up 23 points compared to his last season. Hopefully, he can get his defense back to his 2020 form, but that might be difficult with the new wall in left field. It would be interesting to see if they look to extend him.

Disappointment: Cedric Mullins

In 2021 Ceddy really broke out for the O’s, making the All-Star team and finishing the season with a Silver Slugger award and ninth in American League in MVP voting. This season has not gone as well, losing his stroke at the plate to only being about an average hitter and not performing as well defensively. He looked like he might be a cornerstone for Baltimore but, at the moment, seems more like an average player.

Boston Red Sox

Surprise: J.D Martinez

Martinez has been a fantastic hitter for several years now, but I do not think anyone expected him to be as good as he has been. He is currently fourth in all of MLB in OPS at 1.020 and tied for second on his team in bWAR, which is impressive for a guy who only plays designated hitter. It is a contract year, so that might be some additional motivation for him.

Michael Wacha has also been great this season, but I don’t see it lasting, so I went with Martinez instead.

Disappointment: Bobby Dalbec

I considered going with Nathan Eovaldi here, but his underlying numbers look strong enough to see a future turnaround.

Dalbec was more of a clear choice as he has been awful at the plate after a solid rookie campaign. Sometimes these things can be predictable, especially for a young player with little experience. However, he actually underperformed expected numbers last season, so I figured his numbers would look pretty similar if he were to regress. Boston might have to swap him out for top prospect Triston Casas pretty soon.

New York Yankees

Surprise: Luis Severino

Gleyber Torres was definitely an option here as he completely turned his play around. Still, I think Severino has to be the choice after all his injuries and basically not playing since 2018. Sevvy has returned and looked almost exactly like the pitcher he was four years ago, a rotation leader once again.

Disappointment: Kyle Higashioka

There are some other names to consider for this in Gallo, Hicks, and Loaisiga, but I have reasons for not choosing them. Gallo and Jonny Lasagna have solid underlying numbers to suggest a potential turnaround. And I don’t think Yankee fans expected much out of Hicks anyway for him to be that disappointing.

Higgy has shown promise on the plate, with him underperforming in previous seasons to suggest he could even be better at the plate than he has been. However, he has gone the other direction, losing all production he had with the bat.

Tampa Bay Rays

Surprise: Shane McClanahan

After a promising rookie season, Shane has turned it up a notch. While writing this, he has a 2.06 ERA and 2.52 FIP, also leading the league in strikeouts, with his expected numbers matching up well. His xFIP and SIERA actually look even better at 1.86 and 2.05. The Rays have found yet another stud pitcher to lead their rotation.

Disappointment: Mike Zunino

What a year he had in 2021, eh? Over 30 home runs, a .860 OPS and 4.5 FanGraphs WAR. He has been the antithesis of that season so far in 2022. A .536 OPS with only four home runs, and even his typically great framing has been worse based on Baseball Savant. Francisco Mejia has been solid in covering up for Zunino. Still, him even being an average hitter would help out this lineup.

Toronto Blue Jays

Surprise: Santiago Espinal

Last season he finished as a surprise, and he seems to be doubling down. His numbers are relatively similar regarding his slash line at the plate, but the underlying numbers show the difference. He has already matched his total for doubles and home runs to last season in 49 fewer games. Changing it to be on par or slightly above his expected numbers from overperforming last year. On top of his plus defense, the Jays have a lock at second base.

Disappointment: Jose Berrios

I am sure this is not the type of production Toronto was expecting when they signed Berrios to a seven-year extension. He is currently sitting at a 4.75 ERA and 4.51 FIP, with expected numbers looking about the same. He has been solid in his past two outings, so hopefully, that is a sign he is starting to get back on track.

Houston Astros

Surprise: Jeremy Peña

The sole successor to Carlos Correa has done a fantastic job replacing the former All-Star. Second in the league for WRC+ and tied for the most fWAR at 2.1 among qualified shortstops with Tim Anderson. Also, Peña has had spectacular defense to potentially make him the best shortstop in baseball this season.

Justin Verlander is on the same level here after returning from Tommy John surgery for his age 39 season and being damn near the identical ace we saw back in 2019.

Disappointment: Yuli Gurriel

Gurriel has had a pretty intriguing and inconsistent career. He has overperformed expected numbers in every one of his successful seasons, so it seems like he is just finally regressing. However, with a decrease in his average exit velocity and expected numbers saying he is still overperforming, Gurriel is finally showing his age.

Los Angeles Angels

Surprise: Taylor Ward

Probably the biggest surprise of the whole season, Taylor Ward is currently the best player in baseball by OPS (1.184) and WRC+ (243). He has been up and down from the majors since 2018 but has never shown this level of play. The 28-year-old has shown incredible discipline, and all underlying numbers suggest this is no hot streak. This year, the Angels are looking great, and Ward’s breakout has been a big part.

Disappointment: Reid Detmers

This may seem like an odd choice, given he has thrown a no-hitter this year, but I did expect more from him. A 4.65 ERA and 5.01 FIP with lower strikeout numbers than last season. He could use more time in the minors as he only pitched eight innings in Triple-A and only 62 innings total before being called up. He doesn’t seem to have a consistent mix he uses, and locating has been difficult with everything catching most of the zone.

Jo Adell was also in contention, but I believe he would have figured it out if they could have given him more time, as he is showing in Triple-A. Both Ward and Marsh breaking out now will prevent him from getting much playing time if he gets back.

Oakland Athletics

Surprise: Paul Blackburn

I don’t think anyone expected such a strong season from him this year, especially since he has been up and down from the league since 2017. Blackburn has a 1.70 ERA and 2.72, which will have him as one of the best pitchers in MLB this season. His 3.38 xFIP and 3.73 SIERA suggest there will be some regression but, either way, Oakland seems to have found a solid piece of their rotation … or another trade asset.

Dany Jimenez has also been incredible in the bullpen, but I think Blackburn’s performance has been more surprising.

Disappointment: Christian Pache

Pache was one of the headline pieces from the Matt Olson trade, and he has not fully lived up to expectations. He was raved about for his defense, which has been fantastic this season. However, his hitting has been quite the opposite, with the lowest WRC+ in the league. Expected numbers see him improving but still being below league average. If he can get to at least average, he could be the American Leagues Harrison Bader.

I also considered Kevin Smith; however, I feel like Pache had higher expectations for this season.

Seattle Mariners

Surprise: Eugenio Suárez

Originally sent to Seattle in a dump-off move from the Reds, Suárez has proved himself a great hitter. Currently sitting with a 127 WRC+ and that is with him still underperforming his expected numbers by a wide margin. Especially regarding his slugging percentage, which is 90 points lower. If both Jesse Winker and Suárez play up to their capabilities, that trade with the Cincinnati Reds will be one of the best in recent history.

J.P. Crawford was also considered, but expected numbers see him coming back down to earth.

Disappointment: Jarred Kelenic

Jesse Winker and Robbie Ray were contenders; however, both seem to be just underperforming, which will hopefully straighten itself out. Kelenic, on the other hand, just has not figured it out at the plate with a .509 OPS and 54 WRC+. Even in the minors right now, he is struggling, which could mean this has become a confidence issue. Some prolonged time in the minors will hopefully give him a chance to work things out.

Texas Rangers

Surprise: Martín Pérez

Jonah Heim has also been very surprising this year with his performance at the plate. Still, Martín Pérez’s play has been much more unexpected. This is the best he has looked in his nine-year career, with a 1.60 ERA and 2.43 FIP. That goes deeper, too, with his xFIP at 3.62 and 3.69 SIERA, both the best of his career. I think he will probably be dealt at the deadline if Texas is still out of the playoffs.

Disappointment: Marcus Semien

Semien has been one of the biggest disappointments in the whole league. He is coming off 2021, where he had the most home runs ever by a second baseman and signed a large contract with the Rangers (sounds eerily similar to Salvador Perez).

He did overperform last season by his xBA and xSLG, but nothing saw this coming. Semien has been slightly better in May but still far away from the player the Rangers thought they were getting.