Philadelphia Phillies hope to weather Bryce Harper’s absence

Everything had been going well for the Philadelphia Phillies since they fired Joe Girardi. While there were still issues, particularly in the bullpen, the Phillies had pulled their way back into playoff contention. They entered Tuesday four games over .500 and two games back in the Wild Card hunt, a remarkable turnaround considering that they had been left for dead not too long ago.

But that was then. Now they have to handle missing their best player, Bryce Harper, after he fractured his thumb when hit by a pitch on Saturday. He is set to undergo surgery to stabilize the break and is facing a recovery time of six to eight weeks.

Philadelphia Phillies have to ride out the storm

It is foolish to suggest that the Phillies attempt to find a replacement for Harper in the lineup. He had been in the midst of an impressive season at the plate, posting a 175 OPS+ with 15 homers and 21 doubles in 275 plate appearances. That performance was all the more impressive considering that he is playing through a partially torn UCL that is keeping him from playing the outfield.

And that is the problem. Harper has taken what would have been a middling lineup without him and made it far more dangerous. He had been on pace for another MVP caliber season when he was struck in the thumb. That production cannot be replaced.

Instead, the Phillies need other players to step up. Kyle Schwarber and Rhys Hoskins have been what the Phillies needed in the lineup, but they need more from their other stars. Both J.T. Realmuto and Nick Castellanos have been disappointing this season and will need to return to their accustomed level while Harper is out.

If that happens, the Phillies may be able to stay within striking distance of the playoffs. If Harper was to return at the early part of his expected recovery window, that would allow him to return at some point in August, giving the Phillies some time to make up any needed ground. But in order ride out the storm, they need to get production from their other stars.

The Philadelphia Phillies will be without Bryce Harper for six to eight weeks. They need their other players to step up in his absence.