Grades for all the Philadelphia Phillies who mattered in 2023

The 2023 Philadelphia Phillies post-mortems are done; once again, the South Philly 9 didn't go home with the big trophy befitting a $257 million team. As in '22, "good pitching beat good hitting."

The corollary to this is: The pitchers don’t have to be generally good, experienced, or even impressive. They just have to be good when it counts. Two rookie pitchers for the Arizona Diamondbacks, Brandon Pfaadt and Andrew Saalfrank, shoved large tree branches into the Phillies’ playoff bike spokes, for example.

It’s time to grade the important Philadelphia Phillies on this past season’s team.

Let’s look at the starting ten first. The players’ base and adjusted salaries are given in parentheses, if there is any difference. Otherwise, just what was paid is given, and yes, the salaries do affect the grades.

Bryce Harper ($26M/$27.5M+):  B+. And I can hear the howls already, so all right, this would probably be an A- if he had played the whole year, and yeah, an injury’s an injury, but grades paid to at least the top three moneymakers on the team must reflect whether a full season is played. In Harper’s case, it wasn’t.

There’s no denying Bryce Harper is the “heart and soul” of the current Phillies team. Many times this season, he produced significantly when it was needed. He did not produce significantly in the NLCS, going 5-for-29 (.172) with 3 RBI. He’s still making good progress in playing first base.

Trea Turner ($27.2M+):  B-. Really, a C+ is probably justifiable, considering Turner’s team base-high salary, and his .236 batting average at the end of May and that .242 figure at the end of July. But then, of course, after some warm feelies sent his way from Philly fans at Citizens Bank Park, as has been too thoroughly documented, he hit .333 in August and .299 in September. He drove in over a third of his regular season’s 76 RBI (26) in August alone. He also contributed 30 stolen bases without being caught.

But Turner had a dreadful season in the field, posting a fielding percentage 14 points below the league average of .974. He committed a career-high 23 errors sprinkled among 568 chances and some spectacularly great plays.

He hit .261 in the postseason, but made four errors.

Zack Wheeler ($24.5M):  A. Wheeler is the team’s undisputed ace, and he pitched like one this year. The regular pitcher metrics may not bespeak indisputable glory (13-6, 3.61 ERA), but the starter threw 192.1 innings and posted a career best K/BB ratio of 5.44/1, with a career low of 1.8 walks per nine innings.

Then there was his playoff performance, when he was unbeatable, even in the seventh game of the NLCS, when his team was clearly doomed by the time he took the ball. In that game, Wheeler threw 1.2 hitless, scoreless innings beginning in the seventh inning.

These three players ate up very, very nearly a full third of the salary dollars the Phillies spent this year.

On to the players who filled out the rest of the starting lineup at the end of the season…

J.T. Realmuto ($23.8M+):  B. This is simple. In a B season, J.T. Realmuto is clearly still among the top three catchers in baseball because of his handling of pitchers, his intelligence, and his rare baserunning skill and speed for his position. His caught stealing rate was only 22% this year (less than half his career-best), but keep in mind he had to overcome Craig Kimbrel’s Scarecrow-in-Oz setup and very slow delivery, as well as Aaron Nola’s early struggles with the pitch clock.

Nick Castellanos ($20 M):  A-. (More howls are audible: “What about the playoffs?!?”) The right fielder, however, bounced back from his sub-par first year with the Phillies to lead the team in regular-season RBI (106). That he went cold as ice late in the playoffs after a hot start merely highlights the fact that no one else picked him up. He has also become an above-average outfielder in Philadelphia and was an All-Star this summer.

Kyle Schwarber ($20 M):  B. Kyle Schwarber’s inspiring game-leadoff home runs (11) and walks supposedly make up for his .197 average. His leadership is also unquestioned, and he drove in 104. However, if or when he is pressed into defensive service, he is the worst player available even if he has an actual outfielder’s glove. His OBP (.343, fourth on the team) is also somewhat undercut by the fact that he can not run, really. He was caught both times he tried to steal this season after a huge outlier of a season in ’22, when he was successful 10 of 11 times. That’s right. All his stolen bases you recall were last year.

Alec Bohm ($748 K):  A-. Bohm drove in 97 this year and nearly doubled his career homers with 20 dingers in his fourth season. He also drove his K-rate down to a four-year low of 15.4 percent. The third baseman, once thought to be possibly too tall and awkward to play his position, also exceeded his position’s league fielding average by 15 points, posting a .978 at his primary spot with only four errors. He is also beginning to make some spectacular plays, making him a bargain at his price before his first arbitration-eligible year in in ’24.

Bryson Stott ($734.5K):  A. As he is not eligible for arbitration until ’25, Stott is an even bigger bargain than Bohm. The second-year player is a finalist for the second base NL Gold Glove and raised his batting average by 46 points over his rookie campaign to .280. He appears to be a star in the making, having concentrated, with coaching by Kevin Long and Jean Segura, on putting pitches in play, particularly with two strikes.

Brandon Marsh ($734.5K):  B+. Marsh appears to be settling in as the Phillies left fielder, is productive in general, and was one of the few offensively consistent hitters in the NLDS and NLCS, hitting .342 for the entire postseason. He also doesn’t hurt the team in center if Johan Rojas has a day off or is banged up. Another bargain, not eligible for arbitration until ’25.

Johan Rojas ($720K/$344.5K+):  A-. Johan Rojas was promoted mid-season from Double-A Reading and was the team’s most pleasant surprise, playing what will one day be Gold Glove defense, including a very important catch in the postseason. He also hit .302 with the MLB Phillies, then was mildly insulted, more than once in the playoffs by TBS broadcasters, who kept noting his playoff offensive struggles.

On to all the others deserving grades, beginning with the other starting pitchers…

Aaron Nola ($16M):  B. Aaron Nola represents the Phillies hardest offseason decision as his contract is expiring. The right-hander had neither his best nor worst season until the end, when he dialed up some great performances beginning September 15 against the Cardinals. Unfortunately, that came to a screeching halt in his last appearance against the Diamondbacks in Game 6 of the NLCS when he gave up four earned runs in 4.1 innings.

Still, Nola is one of baseball’s most durable starters, throwing more than 180 innings in five of his nine years thus far, and posting a winning record by 19 games with Phillies teams that were mediocre or worse in his first seven years. His career WHIP is 1.129, and he has finished in the top seven for Cy Young voting three times. A tough decision, indeed.

Ranger Suarez ($2.9M+):  B-. Arbitration eligible in ’24, Suarez represents another sticky matter for Phillies management. A winning and generally effective left-handed starter, he wasn’t actually ready to start a game until May 13 this season. He eventually started 22 games, but won only four. A six-earned-run mess on September 27 against the Pirates pushed his ERA for the season over 4.00. In the NLCS, he might have been 1-0, or 2-0, instead of 1-1, if the Phillies had managed to score three or four runs, respectively, before the he was removed in the fifth inning of Game 7.

Taijuan Walker ($18M):  C+. Walker had something of a fluke season, posting a 4.38 ERA in 31 starts, but benefiting from the Phillies offense. He won 15, lost six, but wasn’t trusted enough by the team to even appear in postseason games. Although 15 wins are evidence of at least some toughness, Philly seems to have overpaid for him.

Cristopher Sanchez ($725K/$510.6K+):  B. Sanchez is on the other side of a coin with Walker, going 3-5 despite a very respectable 3.44 ERA and 1.047 WHIP. He started 18 of his 19 games, but the Phillies didn’t seem to trust the left-hander as they might have if Walker weren’t so expensive. Or maybe he was handled perfectly since his FIP was 55 points higher than his ERA.

Matt Strahm ($7.5M):  A. This versatile starter/reliever started 10 of his 56 game appearances this season, and for his cost, which will be the same next season, he’ll end up as one of Dave Dombrowski’s best decisions if he can duplicate his ’23 numbers (9-5, 3.29 ERA, 3.24 FIP, 1.015 WHIP) in his age-32 campaign.

Michael Lorenzen ($8.5M/$2.7M+):  C+. What do you say about trade acquisition who throws a no-hitter in his second game, then gives up six, four, three, six, four, and four earned runs in his next six appearances (five starts)? “Only in Philadelphia”? Sounds about right.

On to the relievers and backup players…