Pittsburgh Pirates fans cautiously optimistic about their gathered young talent
How 'ready' are the Pirates to contend?
The question of the Pittsburgh Pirates’ readiness to “contend” in 2024 seemed to pop up literally the moment after the Bucs started packing for the offseason last fall. Pittsburgh’s season ended in 2023 with an Oct. 1 3-0 win over the Marlins. The team ended 76-86, and two days later AP writer Will Graves declared the Bucs were ready to go.
The Pirates had followed up one of their famous illusory starts (20-8) with a three-month fall-off, and a slightly better than .500 finish. GM Ben Cherington was a bit muted, but said, “We have a clear mind about what’s next, and that it’s not easy and not supposed to be easy.”
Manager Derek Shelton, however, was a bit more positive and added an interesting angle about his largely young squad: “I’m very encouraged with (August and September) because I think not only are we getting better record-wise, we’re playing better baseball but we’re also and this may sound a little different, we’re getting things out of the way.”
By this he meant players’ “firsts” – that first hit, or first error, or first start – that can sometimes be psychological sticking points for young players.
By December, an MLB.com headline kept the contending notion in place, sort of: “Are the Pirates ready to make a leap in 2024?” Everybody knows that wouldn’t mean a leap to five games under .500.
Does Pirates' Lineup Open 2024 Contention Window?
Well, how open the window to contend is remains debatable, but it’s inarguable that there is a strong, young Pirates core in center fielder Bryan Reynolds (29, All-Star in ’21, ROY-4 in ’19), shortstop Oneil Cruz (25, ROY-6 in ’22) and third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes (27, Gold Glove in ’23, ROY-6 in ’20). Cruz’ injury last April was probably as important to the Pirates not reaching .500 as anything else negative that happened to the team. He is reportedly now pain free and moving smoothly after recovering from a leg fracture.
These three players arguably need to step up this season with solid efforts. A couple probably need to post career bests in some category. For example, Cruz, with a full season’s at-bats under his belt, should easily eclipse 17 home runs and 54 RBI.
I think Oneil Cruz is gonna be OK. pic.twitter.com/3QmlGY4n4w
— Jason Mackey (@JMackeyPG) February 25, 2024
Reynolds needs to get back to a .300 batting average, which he should be capable of any season in the next three, and so forth.
Pirates' Rotation: Where do they stand entering 2024?
After that, the next three most important players in black and gold this season are the expected first three starters, Mitch Keller, Martin Perez, and Marco Gonzales. Or will number three be Roansy Contreras? The Pirates' first three are always changing for some reason.
Last year, the expected Pittsburgh starters in March were, in order, Keller, JT Brubaker, Contreras, Rich Hill, and Vince Velasquez. The leaders in games started turned out to be: Keller, Johan Oviedo, and Hill. (Oviedo is now injured and Hill is gone.) So, let’s say Keller, Perez and Gonzales are the Bucs’ leading starters. In that case, what does the team have?
Keller last season: 4.21 ERA, 13-9, 1.245 WHIP. He kept his ERA below 4.00 through the end of July. It rose after Aug. 3, after the game against the Brewers in which he gave up eight earned runs in five innings. Perez last season for Texas: 4.45 ERA, 10-4, 1.405 WHIP. Perez basically replaces Hill as the veteran starter, minus 11 years in age. Gonzales last season for Seattle: 5.52 ERA, 4-1, 1.460 WHIP – season cut short for forearm nerve surgery on his throwing arm.
I see some cause for concern, even given Keller was an All-Star in ’23 and Perez in ’22. The ERAs could be stronger. Two need to dip below 4.00 for team success, if not all three, however many starts they make. It’s hard to make any prediction about Gonzales. If he’s fully recovered, his career numbers say he is probably a lesser Ranger Suarez, a similar lefty on the Phillies.
The question about whether the Pirates can contend, however, may depend on these six players, given some change is likely among the three leaders in starts.
Temperature of Pirates Fans on 2024 Contention Chances
Are the Pirates fans concerned? I was lucky to consult with Pirate Queen Banshee, a familiar face at Pirates home games and a well-known voice on Twitter/X. Queen Banshee is easily recognized in the North Side ballyard,as she and her husband generally show up to cheer on the Bucs dressed as though they wandered off the set of one of Johnny Depp’s pirate films. (They look great.)
And the Pirate Queen knows what the fans are saying. Asked whether she’s hearing that the fans think the Pirates are improving, she said:
“I’ve heard, read, and been told various opinions [about] what they think it means to improve…. Some think improvement or winning is over .500. Some won’t settle for anything less than NLDS. They won’t even accept a wild card slot because 'Been there. Done that.’”
Adding she personally feels the team is “moving in the right direction,” she lamented the loss of two players to injury: 6-foot-5 pitcher Johan Oviedo (4.31 ERA, 1.373 WHIP in ’23) and catcher Endy Rodriguez – both young and promising, both on the 60-day IL.
“It’s difficult for me to predict what this year will bring. With the Pirates having to scramble to fill those roles, any projection I had about 2024 is lost…,” said Queen Banshee.
One thing Pirates fans are undoubtedly happy about is the return of Andrew McCutchen.
It’s tempting to say that if, say, Perez and Reynolds don’t have career years, the Pirates will struggle to contend. Ditto for a slumping trio of Cruz, Gonzales, and Hayes. The team, of course, has other young players (read, Jack Suwinski) who might fill in during core players’ slumps.
What if Suwinski cut down his strikeouts by 50 while hitting 35 home runs?
Once again, the Pittsburgh Pirates are sort of a who-knows team, but one whose young players’ numbers may belie their actual talent. That talent needs to show up and be in concert for months in a row.