2011 MLB Trade Rumors: Marlins Reject A’s Proposal for Gio Gonzalez

The Miami Marlins want a top of the rotation starting pitcher and are scouring the free agent and trade markets in order to find one.  Their search led them to Oakland where Florida native Gio Gonzalez currently pitches.  Interested in acquiring Gonzalez from the A’s, the Marlins have reportedly “flatly rejected” Oakland’s initial trade proposal which included either Mike Stanton or Logan Morrison.

It’s not surprising to see the A’s asking for such lofty return for Gonzalez.  Oakland’s general manager Billy Beane made it clear from the start that if he were to trade one of his top young arms this winter, he would be looking for ace return.

Clark Spencer of the Miami Herald reports that the A’s and Marlins have spoken recently about Gonzalez.  During their preliminary discussion, Spencer says that Beane proposed a package built around Stanton or Morrison.  Miami balked and the request and now that they have confirmed the asking price they may turn their attention to other possible trade targets.

When rumors first surfaced regarding Gonzalez, it was said that the A’s were looking at several of Miami’s young players that provided significant contributions at the major league level in 2011.  Stanton and Morrison would certainly qualify.

Stanton (22) hit 34 home runs and drove in 87 runs in 2011 while Morrison (24) tallied 23 long balls and 72 RBI’s last season.

As Spencer mentions, Miami’s farm system isn’t “exactly bursting at the seams with highly coveted prospects”.  If the Marlins are hoping to bring in a top starter via trade, they may have to concede some of their young and talented major leaguers.

Beyond Gonzalez, several other starting pitchers are said to be available.  Tampa Bay Rays starter James Shields interests the Marlins and John Danks and Gavin Floyd of the Chicago White Sox and Wandy Rodriguez of the Houston Astros are all rumored to be available this winter.

When talking about Gonzalez and his availability, many reference the Dan Haren deal.  In that trade, Beane and the A’s brought in a ton of young talent including starting pitcher Brett Anderson and outfielder Carlos Gonzalez.

Other than the Marlins, the New York Yankees have been tied to Gonzalez this winter.  FanSided’s own Jon Verburg and Derek Stykalo explored the idea of the Detroit Tigers and Boston Red Sox dealing for Gonzalez as well.

For more on the Athletics and Marlins, be sure to check out Swingin’ A’s and Marlin Maniac.

Topics: Brett Anderson, Carlos Gonzalez, Dan Haren, Gavin Floyd, Gio Gonzalez, James Shields, John Danks, Logan Morrison, Miami Marlins, Mike Stanton, Oakland A's, Wandy Rodriguez

Want more from Call to the Pen?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • ehsank24

    I would not trade Stanton straight up for Gonzalez to be honest and they wanted a package built around him? Insane.

  • blaineblontz

    @ehsank24 Yeah that makes sense to flat reject. What do you think of something built around Morrison? I’m guessing Beane would want two major league ready guys and some other pieces for Gio, is there a young arm that you would pair with Morrison to get a deal done?

  • ehsank24

    @blaineblontz I would have no issues with the Marlins doing a package built around Morrison. I would also include Matt Dominguez. As far as other MLB ready prospects, the A’s would be better off trying to get a lower minor leaguer from the Fish. They have a lot more upside then anything the Marlins have in the higher classes. Marzell Ozuna is a name to watch IMO.

  • https://marlinmaniac.com/ ehsank24

    I would not trade Stanton straight up for Gonzalez to be honest and they wanted a package built around him? Insane.

  • blaineblontz

    @ehsank24 Yeah that makes sense to flat reject. What do you think of something built around Morrison? I’m guessing Beane would want two major league ready guys and some other pieces for Gio, is there a young arm that you would pair with Morrison to get a deal done?

  • https://marlinmaniac.com/ ehsank24

    @blaineblontz I would have no issues with the Marlins doing a package built around Morrison. I would also include Matt Dominguez. As far as other MLB ready prospects, the A’s would be better off trying to get a lower minor leaguer from the Fish. They have a lot more upside then anything the Marlins have in the higher classes. Marzell Ozuna is a name to watch IMO.

  • Robert5286

    Josh Reddick and a prospect for Carlos Quentin would make a ton of sense for both teams. Chicago would lighten it’s payroll with young major leaguer, while Boston would fill a gaping hole in RF with Quentin’s bat.The Sox might have to throw in another prospect closer to the show, as well. Hiding in the grass are two affordable FA’s who could help any team. Mike Macdougall and Reed Johnson.

  • Robert5286

    Not Stanton, but Morrison for Gonzales would be a great deal for the Fish..A starting four of Sanchez,Buerlie,Gonzalez and hopefully, Josh Johnson, would help. They could sign Carlos Beltran to make up for Morrison’s bat.

  • Robert5286

    Josh Reddick and a prospect for Carlos Quentin would make a ton of sense for both teams. Chicago would lighten it’s payroll with young major leaguer, while Boston would fill a gaping hole in RF with Quentin’s bat.The Sox might have to throw in another prospect closer to the show, as well. Hiding in the grass are two affordable FA’s who could help any team. Mike Macdougall and Reed Johnson.

  • Robert5286

    Not Stanton, but Morrison for Gonzales would be a great deal for the Fish..A starting four of Sanchez,Buerlie,Gonzalez and hopefully, Josh Johnson, would help. They could sign Carlos Beltran to make up for Morrison’s bat.

  • Pingback: 2011 MLB Trade Rumors: Marlins Still Seeking Starter - Call to the Pen - A Major League Baseball Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More

  • Pingback: 2011 MLB Trade Rumors: Gio Gonzalez Market Heating Up - Call to the Pen - A Major League Baseball Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More